EXCLUSIVE: Untamed Season 2 Premieres October 25 – Lucy’s Sister Revealed as Potential Enemy

Netflix’s gripping crime thriller Untamed is set to return for its highly anticipated second season on October 25, 2025, promising a fresh wave of mystery, emotional depth, and breathtaking landscapes. After the success of its debut season, which captivated audiences with its moody narrative and stunning Yosemite National Park setting, Untamed Season 2 is poised to dive deeper into the personal and professional struggles of National Park Service Investigative Services Branch (ISB) agent Kyle Turner (Eric Bana). The biggest bombshell? A new plotline centered on Lucy Cook, the murder victim from Season 1, whose story takes an unexpected turn as her long-lost sister emerges—potentially as an adversary working for the enemy. This exclusive article explores what fans can expect from the upcoming season, including plot details, character arcs, and the creative vision behind the series, based on the latest buzz and insights from the web.

A Refresher on Untamed Season 1

Untamed Season 1, which premiered on July 17, 2025, hooked viewers with its atmospheric murder mystery set in Yosemite National Park. The six-episode miniseries followed ISB agent Kyle Turner as he investigated the death of a young woman, initially identified as Jane Doe, later revealed to be Lucy Cook (Ezra Franky). The investigation uncovered dark secrets within the park, including a drug-smuggling operation and personal betrayals tied to Turner’s past. The season’s emotional core revolved around Turner’s grief over the loss of his son, Caleb, and the shocking revelation that his ex-wife, Jill Bodwin (Rosemarie DeWitt), had hired wildlife officer Shane Maguire (Wilson Bethel) to kill Caleb’s murderer, Sean Sanderson. The finale also disclosed that Chief Park Ranger Paul Souter (Sam Neill) was Lucy’s biological father, whose actions inadvertently led to her tragic suicide off El Capitan.

Season 1 ended with Turner leaving Yosemite, having found some closure but still carrying emotional scars. The series’ blend of noir-style detective work, personal drama, and the awe-inspiring backdrop of Yosemite earned it a 79% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a dedicated fanbase eager for more.

Season 2: A New National Park, A New Mystery

While Season 1 was firmly rooted in Yosemite, Season 2 is rumored to shift to a new national park, with fan speculation pointing to locations like the Smoky Mountains, Glacier National Park, or even Hawaii’s volcanic landscapes. This change aligns with the real-life operations of ISB agents, who often move between parks to tackle cases. The anthology-style format teased by co-showrunners Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith suggests that each season could explore a new setting and mystery, keeping the narrative fresh while retaining core characters like Kyle Turner and Naya Vasquez (Lily Santiago).

The central hook of Season 2 revolves around Lucy Cook’s story, which takes a surprising twist. Despite her death in Season 1, new information reveals that Lucy had a sister, previously unmentioned, who becomes a pivotal figure in the upcoming season. According to exclusive reports, Turner’s investigation into a new case uncovers this sister, who has been living under an assumed identity. The shocking twist? She may have been working for the very forces Turner is trying to dismantle—potentially a criminal network tied to the park’s underbelly. This revelation promises to add layers of intrigue, forcing Turner to confront questions of loyalty, betrayal, and the blurred lines between ally and enemy.

Plot Details and Character Arcs

Season 2 picks up with Kyle Turner, now a rogue investigator after his suspension from the ISB at the end of Season 1. No longer bound by official protocols, Turner’s approach is expected to be more unorthodox, reflecting his emotional evolution. Eric Bana, who delivers a raw and compelling performance as Turner, hinted in an interview with Variety that Season 2 will explore “what happens to Kyle after Yosemite, in theory,” suggesting a character grappling with his past while forging a new path.

Naya Vasquez, the ambitious rookie ranger played by Lily Santiago, is likely to take on a more prominent role. After proving her mettle by saving Turner’s life in Season 1, Naya’s investigative skills and personal growth are expected to shine. Santiago expressed enthusiasm for deeper murder investigations and “wilder locations” in an interview with TV Insider, hinting at her character tackling new challenges in a different park.

The introduction of Lucy’s sister is the season’s most tantalizing plot point. While details about her identity and motives remain scarce, her connection to the “enemy” suggests ties to a larger criminal operation—possibly involving environmental crimes, wildlife trafficking, or a park-based conspiracy, as speculated by fans on platforms like Reddit. This storyline could reframe Lucy’s tragic arc from Season 1, revealing new facets of her life and the circumstances that led to her death. Was her sister complicit in the events that drove Lucy to El Capitan? Or is she a victim of the same forces that ensnared Lucy? These questions will likely drive the season’s emotional and narrative stakes.

Other returning characters may include Jill Bodwin, whose actions in Season 1 added complexity to her relationship with Turner. While Sam Neill’s Paul Souter and Wilson Bethel’s Shane Maguire are unlikely to return due to their characters’ deaths, the anthology format allows for new supporting characters to enrich the story. Expect a fresh cast of park rangers, locals, and potential suspects to populate the new setting, each with their own secrets.

Creative Vision and Themes

Co-showrunners Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith have emphasized that Untamed is as much a character study as a mystery series, with themes of family, loss, and redemption at its core. Season 2 is expected to continue this focus, exploring how Turner’s unresolved trauma influences his approach to the new case. The introduction of Lucy’s sister adds a new dimension to the theme of family, raising questions about loyalty and the lengths one goes to protect—or betray—loved ones.

The new national park setting will likely serve as more than a backdrop, becoming a character in its own right, as Yosemite did in Season 1. Whether it’s the misty peaks of the Smoky Mountains or the rugged terrain of Glacier National Park, the environment will amplify the story’s tension and provide unique challenges for Turner and Naya. The showrunners have teased “wilderness challenges” and “new things to learn,” suggesting that survival skills and environmental factors will play a significant role.

Production and Release

While Netflix has not officially confirmed Season 2, the show’s sustained popularity—holding the #1 spot on Netflix’s Top 10 list in the U.S.—and positive critical reception make renewal highly likely. If production follows a similar timeline to Season 1, which filmed from June to September 2024 and premiered in July 2025, Season 2’s October 25, 2025, premiere date aligns with a potential filming schedule starting early in 2025. The six-episode format is expected to continue, offering a tight, binge-worthy narrative.

Why Fans Are Buzzing

The announcement of Season 2, coupled with the tease of Lucy’s sister and her potential ties to the enemy, has sparked fervent discussion online. Fans on X are abuzz with theories about the new park and the sister’s role, with hashtags like #UntamedSeason2 trending. The show’s ability to balance character-driven drama with twist-filled mysteries has resonated with viewers, who appreciate its departure from typical police procedurals. The promise of a new setting and a deeper exploration of Turner’s psyche ensures that Untamed Season 2 will be a must-watch.

Conclusion

Untamed Season 2, premiering October 25, 2025, is shaping up to be a thrilling continuation of Netflix’s hit crime drama. With Kyle Turner navigating a new national park and a complex case involving Lucy Cook’s enigmatic sister, the season promises to deliver more of the emotional depth, stunning visuals, and shocking twists that made Season 1 a standout. As Turner and Naya uncover the truth behind this new mystery, fans can expect a rollercoaster of suspense and heartbreak, set against the untamed beauty of America’s wild landscapes. Mark your calendars—this is one adventure you won’t want to miss.