UNSCRIPTED MOMENT: Nicole Wallace’s Emotional Gaze at Gabriel Guevara During the Filming of Our Fault Has Fans Questioning: Did Something Real Happen Behind the Cameras? 😢

By Grok Entertainment Desk November 16, 2025

In the hazy alchemy of cinema, where scripted lines dissolve into raw vulnerability, few moments linger like an unspoken glance. For the die-hard devotees of Amazon Prime Video’s Culpables trilogy, the final installment Culpa Nuestra (Our Fault), released on October 16, 2025, delivered more than its promised whirlwind of jealousy, chases, and reconciliations. Buried within its feverish narrative of Noah (Nicole Wallace) and Nick (Gabriel Guevara) reuniting at a wedding only to grapple with a surprise pregnancy and a near-fatal stabbing, fans have unearthed what they believe is an unfiltered crack in the facade: Wallace’s emotional gaze at Guevara during a pivotal scene. Was it method acting at its finest, or a fleeting betrayal of unresolved real-life feelings? As clips flood social media, the speculation swirls—did something profoundly personal ignite behind the cameras? 😢

The moment in question unfolds late in Our Fault, during a tense hospital confrontation where Noah, battered and defiant, rejects Nick’s offer to stay by her side on a couch, her pride a shield against his concern. Wallace’s Noah delivers the line with quivering resolve: “You don’t get to decide what’s best for me anymore,” her eyes locking onto Guevara’s with a depth that transcends the script. In the frame, her gaze softens into something achingly tender—tears welling, lips parting as if words fail her—while Guevara’s Nick stands frozen, his brooding facade cracking into quiet desperation. Fans, rewatching on loop, can’t unsee it. “Nicole’s acting was everything. It wasn’t just Noah fighting for her life and her baby… the fact that Nick told her he would stay with her on the couch, and she refused because of her pride… 😭💔,” tweeted @Rmx199_, a clip from the scene racking up 382 likes and thousands of views. Another user, @fleaflopi, captured the collective ache: “This ‘te quiero’ from Nick felt so real, Noah’s face looking at him. Everything reeks of truth. I cry so much and so hard.” With 371 likes, the post ignited a thread of teary emojis and fan edits overlaying the gaze with slow-motion heartbreak ballads.

This isn’t mere projection; the trilogy’s DNA thrives on blurring boundaries. Adapted from Mercedes Ron’s Wattpad sensation, Culpables (Guilty) chronicles the forbidden romance of stepsiblings Noah and Nick amid family betrayals and high-octane drama. Wallace and Guevara first ignited the spark in 2023’s Culpa Mía (My Fault), their on-screen chemistry a powder keg of stolen kisses and revved engines that amassed over 100 million streams. Off-screen, the duo mirrored the heat: joint Instagram posts from Marbella beaches, late-night script sessions that bled into personal confessions, and Guevara’s endearing nickname for Wallace as his “talisman.” Fans dubbed them #GabiCole, shipping the pair with fervor rivaling Twilight‘s heyday. “Their complicity will always be special, and no one can surpass them ❤️😭,” gushed @stacyleister in a behind-the-scenes clip of Guevara playfully helping Wallace with her hands during a take, earning 163 likes.

Yet, as sequels often do, Culpa Tuya (Your Fault) in December 2024 twisted the fairy tale. Rumors of a real-life rift exploded: Wallace unfollowing Guevara on Instagram, cryptic Stories of stormy skies, and a red-carpet freeze-out where she walked away mid-photo op, avoiding his eyes like a live wire. Insiders whispered of on-set blowups—alleged body-shaming jabs from Guevara during intimate scenes, jealousy flares with his then-ex Nuria, and the lingering cloud of his 2023 Venice Film Festival arrest on sexual assault charges (from which he was acquitted). By filming Our Fault in 2024, the air was thick with tension. Promos were siloed: separate interviews, no joint posters on Wallace’s feed, and a viral split-screen Q&A where Wallace cut Guevara off mid-sentence, his shoulders slumping in awkward defeat. “Prime split the interview weirdly—super uncomfortable,” noted @mendessyx, Guevara’s personal assistant’s fan page, with 933 likes on a related post. Wallace, in a Collider interview, reflected on the emotional toll: “Leaving Noah behind… was emotional for me,” admitting the trilogy’s “epic romantic roller coaster” mirrored her own growth.

Enter the unscripted gaze: Filmed amid this frost, how did such intimacy bloom? Behind-the-scenes leaks paint a picture of forced proximity yielding unintended sparks. A YouTube interview has the stars dissecting favorites: Wallace gushing over a goodbye scene “full of subtext… a lot of it that had nothing to do with Nick and more of the whole baby situation,” her voice catching. Guevara, in parallel, praises his character’s “evolution,” but fans zoom in on his lingering pauses. “His body language and lingering gazes speak louder than the dialogue, revealing a man torn between pride and longing,” raved an IMDb review of his “nuanced performance.” On X, @Mumu07313 shared a BTS clip: “It’s so impossible to watch these and not want them together 😍… if looks could talk 🐣,” the video of Wallace’s eyes darting to Guevara mid-laugh hitting 14 likes. Skeptics counter with professionalism: “It’s not that you can fake it, it’s that you can act it… Our work is about creating a world where your emotions and your connection feel real, even if they’re not,” Wallace explained in a clip shared by @mendessyx, viewed over 24,000 times.

Social media has become a battlefield of feels. Optimists see redemption in the gaze: “Por cierto… no le hagáis ni puto caso a esas que dicen que se nota en la película que Nicole está enfadada… En la película solo se ve y se siente la conexión y la química que SIEMPRE los ha unido,” posted @Issaa__12, with 224 likes urging fans to cherish the “truth” on screen. @stacyleister debunked feud myths: “I’ve seen people say that there’s no chemistry… But that’s a lie,” threading evidence of their “special” bond. Cynics, though, dredge the dirt: Reddit’s r/VindictaRateCelebs alleges Wallace vowed never to work with Guevara again post-filming, citing his “body shaming” likes and girlfriend María de Nati’s jealousy-fueled photo purges. “They were done filming the 3rd… and Nicole said she doesn’t want to work in any movies with him anymore,” one user claimed, sparking 114 votes in debate. Even in promo vids, fans nitpick: “He’s also getting emotional… I miss them interacting so much!” lamented a commenter on a note-card reading clip, while others slammed the “zero level of professionalism.”

Theories abound. Some posit the gaze as catharsis—a private exorcism of their fallout, channeled into Noah’s vulnerability. “I was able to be very distinctive… when I was filming Culpa Tuya and Culpa Nuestra,” Wallace told Yahoo, hinting at emotional compartmentalization. Guevara echoes maturity: “The most important thing… finding honesty and vulnerability,” adding a layer of meta-truth. Others whisper of rekindled embers; a November 14 café sighting (as reported in our prior coverage) showed them huddled, heads close, no smiles but undeniable gravity. “Maybe I’m crazy, but I think Gabriel may try to get Nicole on his good side again. She looked sad and he looked very optimistic. Time to heal kids ❤️,” speculated @Christi16930994, her post drawing 212 likes. @alexia_salvator highlighted Guevara’s subtle nods to Wallace in interviews: “Gabriel mentioning Nicole always when he can… before even filming the first movie… a huge fandom was created,” with 236 likes.

Critics temper the hype. Hauterrfly’s review called Our Fault a “hot mess without the heat,” praising Wallace’s “natural” conveyance of unease but faulting Guevara’s Nick for lacking investment. “The emotional disconnect… In Culpa Mia, I cared… But in Culpa Nuestra, I didn’t feel invested,” the piece lamented, suggesting the gaze might be Wallace carrying the film solo. Yet, for actors, intimacy is the job. “Wallace and Guevara give performances that are both emotionally charged and compelling,” noted The Daily Jagran of Your Fault‘s dialogues, a sentiment echoing into the trilogy’s close.

As Our Fault surges past 10 million views, the gaze endures as a Rorschach test for fandom. Is it proof of lingering love, a scar of betrayal, or the magic of make-believe? @litebluez captured the distraction: “She couldn’t focus… Gabriel is distracting indeed,” in a BTS where Wallace fumbles, eyes on him—161 likes and counting. @NiyWallace72248, a Wallace fan page, pleads for nuance: “Despite their argument, no one is a demon here,” reminding that castmates like Víctor and Eva still adore them as siblings. In a Hollywood starved for authenticity, this unscripted flicker—real or rendered—reminds us why we ship: because sometimes, the eyes don’t lie, even when the heart does.

Wallace, fresh off an Amazon talent deal, teases “a new side” in upcoming roles like The House of Spirits. Guevara eyes indies, but both carry Noah and Nick’s ghosts. If the gaze was a goodbye, it’s poetic; if a spark, the drama’s far from over. Fans, wipe those tears—Culpables taught us faults forge the fiercest loves.