When Longmire was canceled the first time, fans were heartbroken — until Netflix swooped in and saved the series, giving it a second chance and three more seasons that kept the story alive. But just as the show regained momentum and the characters hit their stride, Netflix made the unexpected call to end it permanently.
For years, viewers have asked the same question: Why stop a series with loyal fans, solid viewership, and a dedicated following?
The truth runs much deeper than simple numbers.
Behind the scenes were complicated rights issues, tangled studio ownership, shifting platform strategies, and internal decisions that had little to do with the show’s popularity.
It’s a revealing look at how modern streaming really works — and why even a beloved, steady performer isn’t always guaranteed a future. For longtime fans, it finally explains the abrupt finale. For anyone curious about the TV industry today, it’s a reminder that the decisions made behind closed doors are far more complex than they appear 👇👏 READ MORE BELOW
******************
The Cancellation Conundrum: Why Netflix Pulled the Plug on Longmire Despite Its Die-Hard Fans and Solid Numbers
When Longmire first got canceled, fans were devastated—until Netflix stepped in and revived the series, giving it new life and three more seasons. But then, just as the story found its footing again, the streaming giant made the unexpected decision to end the show for good. Many viewers have wondered why a series with strong loyalty, steady viewership, and a passionate fanbase didn’t continue. The answer, as it turns out, goes far deeper than ratings. Behind the scenes were rights issues, studio ownership complications, shifting platform priorities, and strategic decisions that had nothing to do with how much people loved the show. It’s a fascinating look at how the streaming world works—and why even a successful series isn’t always guaranteed a future. For longtime fans, it explains the surprising ending. For anyone curious about how television decisions are made today, it reveals just how complex the landscape has become.
At its peak, Longmire was a neo-Western gem, blending gritty crime procedural with the vast, unforgiving beauty of Wyoming’s Absaroka County. Based on Craig Johnson’s bestselling Walt Longmire Mysteries novels, the series starred Australian actor Robert Taylor as the laconic, widowed sheriff Walt Longmire—a man haunted by his wife’s unsolved murder while navigating tribal politics, small-town corruption, and personal demons. Joined by his sharp-tongued deputy Vic Moretti (Katee Sackhoff), best friend Henry Standing Bear (Lou Diamond Phillips), and daughter Cady (Cassidy Freeman), Walt unraveled cases that delved into Native American heritage, oil barons’ greed, and the moral gray areas of justice. Premiering on A&E in 2012, it quickly became the network’s highest-rated original drama, drawing nearly 6 million viewers per episode in its first season. Critics lauded its authentic portrayal of rural America, with an 88% Rotten Tomatoes score across six seasons, praising Taylor’s stoic charisma and the show’s thoughtful exploration of cultural tensions. Yet, despite this acclaim, Longmire met an abrupt end—not once, but twice—highlighting the precarious economics of TV production.
The first cancellation came in August 2014, after three successful seasons on A&E. Viewership had dipped slightly from 4.2 million to 3.9 million for the season 3 finale, but that was still robust for cable—outpacing shows like Mad Men or early Breaking Bad. A&E’s official line? The show appealed to an “older demographic” unappealing to advertisers chasing younger eyeballs. But insiders told The Hollywood Reporter a different story: It was all about ownership. Produced by Warner Horizon Television (now Warner Bros. Television), Longmire was an external studio project. A&E, like many networks, preferred in-house productions to maximize profits through syndication and international sales. They aggressively tried to buy the rights from Warner Bros., but the studio—knowing they had a hit—refused. “The issue with Longmire is more about the ownership than the age of the audience,” one exec confided. “The studio model is broken and networks just aren’t able to monetize series that underperform in the key demos advertisers covet if they don’t own a piece of it.” In a classic case of sour grapes, A&E canceled the show, shopping it elsewhere despite its dominance.
Enter Netflix, the white knight of canceled series in the early streaming era. Just three months later, in November 2014, the platform scooped up Longmire for seasons 4-6, becoming one of its first major Original revivals alongside Arrested Development. This was a bold move for Netflix, then pivoting from DVD rentals to premium content. Longmire fit perfectly: Its bingeable format, character-driven arcs, and lack of ad interruptions appealed to subscribers craving uninterrupted storytelling. Seasons 4 and 5 thrived, with the show reportedly becoming one of Netflix’s highest-rated original dramas. Johnson himself noted in a 2022 Cowboy State Daily interview: “It quickly became one of the highest-rated, original-content shows they’ve ever had. Smooth sailing for two more seasons.” Viewership data was scarce—Netflix guards it closely—but the series consistently logged millions of hours watched annually, per engagement reports. Fans binged relentlessly; on Reddit’s r/longmire, threads buzz with rewatches, with one user confessing to 10 full run-throughs.
So why end it after season 6, premiering November 2017? History repeated itself, verbatim. As season 5 wrapped, Netflix approached Warner Bros. with an offer to buy the IP outright, eyeing long-term control for spin-offs, movies, or global licensing. Warner Bros. declined again, prioritizing their own portfolio. Unlike A&E, Netflix opted for grace: They greenlit a 10-episode final season to provide closure, allowing Walt to confront his wife’s killer and find tentative peace. “Netflix wanted Warner Brothers to sell ‘Longmire’ to them,” Johnson recounted. “Once again, Warner Brothers wouldn’t bite, but at least this time Netflix was gracious enough to allow the show a final season to wrap things up.” This wasn’t about flagging popularity—Longmire was thriving. It was pure business: Streaming platforms crave full ownership to amortize costs across windows (SVOD, AVOD, FAST) and territories. Leasing from Warner meant Netflix paid hefty licensing fees without reaping full backend profits.
Layered atop this were broader industry shifts. By 2017, Netflix was in an arms race with rivals like Hulu and Amazon, pouring billions into tentpole Originals (Stranger Things, The Crown) that skewed younger and more viral. Longmire‘s mature audience (primarily 35+), while loyal, didn’t align with the youth-focused algorithms driving social buzz. Production costs also escalated: Actor salaries rise with success (Taylor reportedly earned a bump post-revival), and location shooting in New Mexico’s Valles Caldera added logistical heft. Many deals cap at six seasons to renegotiate, but here, the rights impasse sealed it. As Looper noted, “Shows also get more expensive the longer they go on, largely because of these contracts.” Warner Bros., eyeing their burgeoning WarnerMedia library (pre-merger with Discovery), held firm, betting on future value.
The cancellation rippled through fandom like a prairie fire. Petitions garnered thousands of signatures; X (formerly Twitter) lit up with pleas like, “I still don’t understand why it was originally canceled or again with Netflix.” One user fumed, “Before it was saved by Netflix after season 3 ended on a cliffhanger, Longmire was canceled for… ‘it was only viewed by old people’. That’s the most bullshit reason I ever heard of.” Johnson, ever the cowboy poet, fueled speculation in 2022: “They would like to further the story but they had to wait until the Netflix contract expired.” Fast-forward to 2024: As Longmire‘s Netflix license expired, all six seasons departed the U.S. platform on January 1, 2025, landing on Paramount+—a fitting home for Westerns amid Yellowstone‘s shadow. Johnson celebrated by canceling his Netflix sub, quipping on Facebook: “I took a great deal of satisfaction… when I got to the box where they asked why and simply wrote… LONGMIRE.” “Now free from the sweetheart deal with Netflix,” he added, hinting at lopsided early-streaming pacts favoring platforms.
This saga underscores streaming’s opaque machinery. Unlike linear TV, where Nielsen ratings rule, Netflix metrics prioritize completion rates and global hours viewed—data points often revealed too late. Ownership battles, like Warner’s refusal, echo across the industry: Think The Office jumping from NBCUniversal to Peacock, or Friends to Max. Post-2023 Hollywood strikes, guilds pushed for transparency, but studios still wield IP like a sheriff’s badge. Longmire‘s fate mirrors The Killing or Bloodline—revived then shelved when buyouts fail. For creators like Coveny and Baldwin, it meant crafting a poignant finale: Walt hangs up his hat, but loose threads (Cady’s activism, Vic’s romance) dangle for Johnson’s 20+ novels, including 2024’s Tooth and Claw and 2025’s Return to Sender.
Yet hope lingers on the horizon. With Warner Bros. Discovery launching a consolidated streamer in 2025, whispers of a Longmire revival—perhaps on Max—grow louder. Taylor, now 62 and “the right age to play Walt,” expressed interest in 2024 interviews. Phillips echoed, “Boy Howdy!” on X. Reddit speculates a reboot with fresh faces, aligning closer to the books. Johnson teases: “Warner Brothers, now free… will finally consider reviving the show.” In a post-Yellowstone boom, where Westerns like 1883 thrive, Longmire‘s timely themes—Indigenous rights, environmental clashes—feel prescient.
Longmire‘s cancellations weren’t indictments of quality but collateral in the content wars. It gifted fans 63 episodes of quiet heroism, proving good triumphs not with fanfare, but fidelity. As Walt might say, “Sometimes the truth is just a matter of perspective.” In TV’s wild frontier, that perspective shifts with every deal. For now, saddle up on Paramount+—and keep an eye on the trail for season 7.
