Multiple additional gloves found by The Post in same area near Nancy Guthrie’s house where FBI found potential evidence

TUCSON, Arizona — Multiple discarded gloves were found by The Post in the same area where the FBI collected a black glove investigators think could be tied to the abduction of Nancy Guthrie.

The Post discovered three additional gloves Sunday afternoon in Catalina Foothills, roughly two miles from the Tucson home of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie’s mother.

It’s not known whether any of the abandoned gloves are connected to the crime – but their prevalence in an area police have been scouring over the two weeks since 84-year-old Nancy vanished suggested the search had some holes in it.
7
A blue glove found near the southbound side of a highway that runs through the Catalina Foothills neighborhood where Nancy Guthrie lives.Jared Downing/NY Post

The Post alerted the Pima County Sheriff’s Department about the finds, which come as investigators got a possible bombshell DNA hit on a black nitrile glove that appears to match the pair Nancy’s masked kidnapper wore while filmed tinkering with her home doorbell camera on Feb. 1.

Each of the gloves found by The Post were close enough to the highway to have been tossed from a speeding car, and were along a road the kidnapper would likely have taken if fleeing Nancy’s home towards Tucson or Mexico.

They included a leather work glove, a woven blue glove and a red glove which appeared to have been peeled from a hand before being left behind. Each was out in the open and easily visible from the highway running through the Catalina Foothills where Nancy lives.

The area where they were discovered is a secluded spot with no houses or buildings, but with various side streets leading into suburban subdivisions.

7
A red glove discovered near Nancy Guthrie’s house.Jared Downing/NY Post

7
A yellow glove found during the search for Nancy Guthrie.Jared Downing/NY Post
Though two miles from Nancy’s home, the gloves were found in the same general location as the black glove the FBI got a DNA sample from — the results of which they are still waiting to see after testing.

And while Nancy’s abductor was seen with black synthetic gloves in the chilling security footage from the night of Nancy’s kidnapping, they were believed to have been wearing another pair underneath – suggesting the items discovered by The Post could well be part of the case, or at least are worthy of investigation.

7
A blue glove near the southbound side of a highway near to where Nancy Guthrie lives.James Keivom for NY PostBut many gloves have been collected in the investigation, with at least 16 being recovered by police last week in the same area — and it’s not uncommon to see gloves and other litter across the Arizona roadway desert.

7
The glove worn by the suspect seen in the surveillance footage taken from Nancy Guthrie’s surveillance camera.FBI

7
A glove recovered by the FBI near Guthrie’s home on Feb. 11, 2026.Andy Johnstone for NY Post
Despite those discoveries, investigators appear to be little closer to locating Nancy than the day she was reported missing on Feb. 1.

The octogenarian vanished after her son-in-law drove her home on Jan. 31 from a night of dinner and game playing with family, and was reported missing the next day when she failed to arrive at a friend’s to watch a stream of their Sunday church service.

7
View of where several discarded gloves were seen in the Catalina Foothills area on Sunday.James Keivom for NY Post
A series of unconfirmed ransom notes appeared within days and demanded millions, but they provided no proof of life and their deadlines came and went without event.

And at least five different people have been detained – one last week, and four on Friday following an SWAT raid near Nancy’s home – but all were quickly released with no apparent ground being made.

No suspects have been named, despite the FBI pouring resources into the Pima County Sheriff’s Department investigation.