It’s the question we’re all asking.

Spoilers below.

Somebody get Maury Povich in touch with Georgia Miller. The “Mayoress Murderess” of Wellsbury and co-lead protagonist of Netflix’s hit dramedy Ginny & Georgia is officially pregnant again—for real this time!—and she might need some help determining paternity.

In season 3, Georgia fakes a pregnancy using her daughter’s (real) positive pregnancy test, so as to convince her husband, Mayor Paul Randolph, not to divorce her during her ongoing murder trial. But before she makes this objectively awful decision, Georgia first comforts her daughter, Ginny, after the latter has an abortion. As the two cuddle on the couch, Georgia shares that, when she herself was pregnant as a teenager, she wanted “milk, just all the time. Straight from the carton. I would’ve sucked a cow.” She also jokes to Ginny, “We are very fertile. Men sneeze at me, I’m ovulatin’. I had two kids before I could legally order a margarita.”

Both throwaway lines serve as foreshadowing for what’s to come in the finale episode, when a freed Georgia trots through the kitchen, drinking a quart of milk straight from the carton. “Mom,” a startled Ginny begins, “didn’t you say you drink milk when you’re pregnant?” The look on Georgia’s face quickly confirms Ginny’s suspicions.

So has show creator Sarah Lampert, who asserts that Georgia is indeed pregnant. The big question everyone’s asking, then: Who’s the father? As Lampert joked to Netflix’s Tudum, “Ginny gets pregnant, Georgia fakes a pregnancy, and then Georgia really gets pregnant, and we don’t know who the dad is. And when you say these things out loud, you’re like, ‘What in the world is this show?!’” (A fair question.)

There are two potential options for the baby’s father, as far as the audience knows: Mayor Paul and Blue Farm Café owner Joe, who first met Georgia as a teenager. Earlier in the season, Georgia sleeps with her then-husband Paul in a last-ditch effort to make their marriage work, before she makes the false pregnancy claim. Later, Paul leaves her and she makes the decision to skip town and dodge her trial. Joe shows up at her door hours before she makes a run for it, and the two end up sleeping together.

“In that moment, who shows up, but Joe, and he’s not there to make a move,” Lampert told Deadline. “He’s not there in a romantic way…He’s like, ‘Oh, man, she really needs a friend.’ So there’s a little bit of an opening there for them to appreciate new things about each other. Because for him, it’s always been this infatuation.” And if her reciprocation is any indicator, Georgia has feelings for him, too.

So, who is the father of her unborn child? By the end of the season, it’s clear that Paul and Georgia’s relationship is officially over. There’s little but hurt between them now, which has led Brianne Howey, who plays Georgia, to theorize that Joe would make for a better dad. “Seeing the way things ended [between Georgia and Paul], seeing all of our true colors, and what we brought out of one another, I think the healthiest option for everyone was probably for that relationship to dissolve,” Howey told Tudum. “And perhaps someone new is about to be a dad,” she teases.

Added Raymond Ablack, who plays Joe, “I would die of a broken heart [if Paul were the father].”

Lampert told TVLine in a post-finale interview that, despite some early “debate,” the Ginny & Georgia writers’ room has indeed “landed on whose baby it is.” Still, she insisted in a separate interview with Deadline that she can always change her mind. “Here’s what I’ll say about that,” she told the outlet. “I know whose baby she’s carrying, but I went into the writer’s room this season and I said, ‘Here’s who the daddy is. Change my mind.’ So it’s live wire in there. I’m telling you right now, I am open to being convinced otherwise.”

Clearly, when it comes to love affairs, so is Georgia. After she turned down Joe’s advances in the season 3 finale, she might have to reconsider her relationship with him when season 4 comes around. Until then, she’ll just have to frequent the dairy aisle.

This story will be updated.