Greg Gutfeld’s Baby’s Middle Name Contains 3 Mysterious Letters – Fans Speculate It’s a Hidden Message to Longtime Fans of the Gutfeld Show! 📺🔎

Greg Gutfeld, the sharp-tongued host of Gutfeld! and co-host of The Five on Fox News, has always had a knack for keeping his audience guessing. Known for his irreverent humor and cryptic social media posts, Gutfeld has sparked a frenzy among fans with the revelation of his second child’s middle name—a three-letter moniker that has the internet buzzing with theories. Born in March 2025 to Gutfeld, 60, and his wife, Elena Moussa, 42, their son, Riley, carries the middle name “JAM,” a choice that has fans speculating it’s a hidden tribute to longtime viewers of Gutfeld!. As the mystery unfolds, one thing is clear: Gutfeld’s knack for blending personal milestones with playful nods to his audience has only deepened his connection with his loyal fanbase.

A Growing Family and a Curious Clue

Gutfeld’s family life has been a whirlwind since the arrival of his first child, Mira, in December 2024, followed swiftly by Riley in March 2025. The couple, married since 2004, kept both pregnancies private, with Gutfeld announcing Mira’s birth via a statement read by The Five co-host Dana Perino and Riley’s arrival through a cryptic X post: “Riley JAM Gutfeld is here. Gus is jealous, Elena’s exhausted, and I’m still bad at diapers.” The inclusion of “JAM” as Riley’s middle name caught fans off guard, sparking a wave of speculation on X and fan forums about its meaning.

The announcement came during Gutfeld’s six-month hiatus from Fox News, which began in April 2025 to focus on fatherhood. Fans, already eager for his return to Gutfeld! and The Five, seized on the middle name as a potential easter egg, a hallmark of Gutfeld’s playful engagement with his audience. “Greg’s too clever to pick ‘JAM’ randomly,” one X user posted. “It’s gotta be a shoutout to the Gutfeld! crew or something from Red Eye days.” Another wrote, “Three letters? Sounds like a code for longtime fans. I’m rewatching old episodes for clues!”

The JAM Theory: A Nod to Joe Machi?

The leading fan theory centers on Joe Machi, a stand-up comedian and frequent Gutfeld! panelist since the show transitioned to weeknights in 2021. Machi, known for his deadpan delivery and quirky humor, has become a fan favorite, often stealing the show with his offbeat one-liners. Fans speculate that “JAM” stands for Joe Anthony Machi, a tribute to the comedian who Gutfeld has praised as “the secret sauce” of Gutfeld!’s success. The theory gained traction after a March 2025 X post from Machi, who jokingly wrote, “Congrats to Greg on baby Riley. I’m honored to be the godfather… or at least the guy who brings snacks.” Fans interpreted this as a hint that Machi’s influence runs deeper than on-air appearances.

“Greg’s always dropping hints about the show’s inner circle,” a Reddit thread on r/Gutfeld theorized. “JAM for Joe Machi makes sense—Greg loves rewarding loyalty, and Joe’s been with him since the Greg Gutfeld Show days.” The speculation was fueled by Gutfeld’s history of honoring close allies, such as naming Riley after the late Power Trip singer Riley Gale, a friend who inspired him during a personal crisis in 2020, as revealed by Andy Levy on The Blaze. Could “JAM” be another gesture of gratitude to a key figure in Gutfeld’s orbit?

Alternative Theories: From Music to Mischief

Not all fans are convinced that “JAM” points to Machi. Some propose it’s a nod to Gutfeld’s love of music, particularly his passion for hard rock and heavy metal. A vocal fan of bands like Power Trip and GWAR, Gutfeld has often woven music references into his shows, even playing Power Trip’s Nightmare Logic on air after Gale’s death. On X, a user suggested, “JAM could stand for ‘Just Another Metalhead,’ a wink to Greg’s rock roots and his hope that Riley grows up with a killer playlist.” Another fan theorized it’s an acronym for “Jolt of Awesome Music,” tying into Gutfeld’s tendency to infuse Gutfeld! with high-energy segments.

Others see “JAM” as pure Gutfeld mischief, a red herring designed to keep fans talking. “Greg’s a troll at heart,” one X post read. “JAM probably means nothing, and he’s just laughing at us scrambling to decode it.” This aligns with Gutfeld’s history of playful misdirection, like his 2024 Gutfeld! segment “Greg’s Leftovers,” where he reads unused jokes to mess with the audience. His 2008 book, Lessons from the Land of Pork Scratchings, is filled with similar tongue-in-cheek humor, suggesting “JAM” could be a deliberate tease.

A Family Man with a Showman’s Flair

Regardless of its true meaning, “JAM” has deepened Gutfeld’s bond with his audience, who relish the chance to play detective. The mystery unfolds against the backdrop of Gutfeld’s evolving role as a father. Settled in their $10.5 million SoHo loft, purchased in July 2024, Gutfeld and Moussa are raising Mira and Riley in a space that once belonged to Robin Williams, a comedic icon Gutfeld admired. The loft’s child-friendly bedrooms, seen in listing photos, reflect the couple’s commitment to their growing family, while their South Salem lake house offers a quiet escape.

Gutfeld’s hiatus has been a balancing act, with Kat Timpf, Tyrus, and Tom Shillue filling in on Gutfeld!. Fans have praised the guest hosts but eagerly await Gutfeld’s return in October 2025, especially after his $50 million Fox News contract extension was reportedly finalized in April 2025, per Variety. “Greg’s absence makes the show feel off,” an X user posted. “JAM’s got me hyped for his comeback—bet he’ll drop the truth on air.” Another fan speculated that Gutfeld might address the middle name in a “Greg’s Leftovers” segment, turning the mystery into a comedic bit.

The Emotional Core of JAM

While fans dissect “JAM” for hidden messages, some see it as a reflection of Gutfeld’s softer side. His decision to name Riley after a friend who reshaped his perspective suggests a pattern of meaningful tributes. Andy Levy, speaking on The Blaze in March 2025, described Gutfeld’s emotional depth: “Greg hides it behind jokes, but he’s fiercely loyal. Naming his kid Riley was about honoring a moment that mattered.” Could “JAM” be another such gesture, perhaps tied to a personal or professional milestone Gutfeld has kept private?

Moussa, the anchor of their family, has been instrumental in navigating this new chapter. Her rare Instagram Stories, like a February 2025 post showing a cozy nursery corner, hint at the warmth of their home life. Gutfeld, who admitted on The Five in January 2025 that he’s “terrible at everything” parenting-related, relies on Moussa’s strength, joking, “Elena’s the CEO, I’m just the intern.” Their French bulldog, Gus, remains a beloved fixture, with Gutfeld posting in April 2025, “Gus is demoted to third favorite now, but he’s still got my vote.”

A Message to the Fans?

As Gutfeld prepares to return to Fox News, the “JAM” mystery keeps fans engaged, a testament to his ability to blend personal milestones with showbiz flair. Whether it’s a tribute to Joe Machi, a nod to his musical passions, or a classic Gutfeld prank, the three letters have sparked a conversation that transcends the screen. On X, the hashtag #RileyJAM has trended sporadically, with fans sharing theories and rewatching Gutfeld! episodes for clues. “If JAM is for Machi, I’m crying,” one user wrote. “If it’s just Greg messing with us, I’m still here for it.”

For now, the truth behind “JAM” remains locked in Gutfeld’s playbook, a puzzle for fans to ponder as they await his October 2025 return. In the meantime, Riley JAM Gutfeld and his sister, Mira, are growing up in a home filled with love, laughter, and just a hint of mystery—exactly the kind of legacy Gutfeld’s fans have come to expect from the king of late-night cable.