Sullivan’s Crossing is finally having its day in the sun.

Based on a book series by Robyn Carr (yes, the same woman who blessed us with Virgin River), the small-town drama recently became the No. 1 show in the world when its first two seasons arrived on Netflix. Just as they regularly devour Virgin River when a new season hits the streamer, fans can’t get enough of this sleeper hit, which previously enjoyed a slightly quieter life on CTV in Canada and The CW in the U.S.

The certified comfort-watch stars Morgan Kohan as gifted neurosurgeon Maggie Sullivan, who returns to her coastal hometown when she finds herself – and her career – in a crisis. Seeking a fresh start, she also discovers new romance with handyman (and secret lawyer) Cal, played by Chad Michael Murray. And who better to cast as Maggie’s father than everyone’s favorite Gilmore Guy, Scott Patterson?

Little do many of those Netflix viewers realize, there’s an entire third season of Sullivan’s Crossing that previously aired on TV but has yet to hit the streamer (that date remains TBD), plus a just-ordered fourth season already on the way. But what does the future hold for the residents of this tiny TV titan?