Pregnancy Confession: Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4’s October 12 Release Uncovers Maggie’s Pregnancy Revelation—With Cal and Others in the Fatherhood Mix

The quaint town of Timberlake, Nova Scotia, is gearing up for another emotional whirlwind as Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4 approaches its October 12, 2025, premiere on CTV and The CW. The Canadian romantic drama, adapted from Robyn Carr’s beloved novel series, has kept fans on edge with its blend of small-town charm and high-stakes personal drama. At the heart of the series is Maggie Sullivan (Morgan Kohan), a neurosurgeon whose return to her roots has sparked love, conflict, and shocking revelations. Season 3’s cliffhanger introduced Liam (Marcus Rosner), who claimed to be Maggie’s husband, threatening her romance with Cal Jones (Chad Michael Murray). Now, buzz surrounding Season 4 points to a new bombshell: Maggie’s pregnancy revelation, with questions swirling about who the father—or father figure—might be. Here’s a 1,000-word exploration of what this means for Maggie, Cal, and the future of Sullivan’s Crossing.

A Romance Tested by Secrets

Maggie and Cal’s relationship has been the emotional cornerstone of Sullivan’s Crossing since its 2023 debut. Their slow-burn romance, sparked when Maggie fled legal troubles in Boston to reconnect with her estranged father, Sully (Scott Patterson), has endured numerous challenges. From Maggie’s miscarriage in Season 2 to Cal’s grief over his late wife, the couple has navigated grief, trust issues, and external pressures like Maggie’s ex-boyfriend Andrew (Allan Hawco). By Season 3’s finale, Maggie chose to stay in Timberlake, opening a medical practice and committing to Cal, signaling a hopeful future. But Liam’s arrival, claiming to be her husband, threw their plans into disarray, setting the stage for Season 4’s drama.

The pregnancy revelation, teased in fan discussions and entertainment coverage, adds another layer of complexity. Maggie’s previous pregnancy in Season 2 ended in miscarriage, with Andrew confirmed as the father. The loss was a pivotal moment, highlighting Cal’s unwavering support as Maggie grieved. Now, with a new pregnancy in Season 4, the question of paternity—and who will step up as a father figure—looms large. Social media platforms like X are buzzing with speculation, with users like @goodkidbuckley expressing frustration over underdeveloped pregnancy arcs in similar shows, hoping Sullivan’s Crossing gives Maggie’s storyline the depth it deserves.

The Paternity Puzzle: Is Cal the Father?

The most pressing question for fans is whether Cal is the father of Maggie’s baby. In Carr’s book series, Maggie and Cal marry early and eventually have a daughter, Elizabeth, suggesting a future where they build a family. However, the TV adaptation has diverged from the books, introducing Liam as Maggie’s secret husband and delaying the couple’s happily-ever-after. Maggie’s decision to stay in Timberlake with Cal in Season 3 implies a deepening commitment, but Liam’s claim raises doubts about her past. If Maggie and Liam were married, could he be the father? The Season 3 finale’s timing, where Maggie and Cal solidify their relationship just before Liam’s arrival, suggests her pregnancy might align with her time with Cal. Yet, the show’s penchant for twists—described by showrunner Roma Roth as a “pretty big shoe drop” for Season 4—leaves room for ambiguity.

Cal’s character adds another dimension to the paternity question. His gentle handling of a newborn in Season 2’s “Eye of the Storm” episode prompted Maggie to see him as a potential father, despite his Season 3 statement that he doesn’t envision children in his future. This hesitation could complicate his response to Maggie’s pregnancy, especially if he’s not the biological father. Murray, in a 2023 Parade interview, described Sullivan’s Crossing as a place for healing, suggesting Cal’s growth might lead him to embrace a fatherly role, biological or not. Fans on X, like @CassClips, have noted the emotional weight of pregnancy-related storylines, hoping the show handles Maggie’s confession with sensitivity.

Liam’s Role: Father or Disruptor?

Liam’s introduction as Maggie’s husband introduces a potential rival for the father figure role. Described in Season 3 as a “summer fling,” Liam’s claim suggests a deeper history. A letter Maggie wrote to him, found by Cal, indicated she prioritized her career over their relationship, never mentioning a divorce. This secrecy has sparked fan backlash, with X users like @esnybarnes decrying Maggie’s omission as a betrayal of Cal’s trust. If Liam is the father, it could mirror dramatic TV tropes where past lovers reemerge to claim parental rights, as seen in posts comparing Maggie’s situation to other shows’ love triangles.

However, Liam’s role might be more about disruption than paternity. Kohan told Swooon in July 2025 that Maggie’s failure to disclose her marriage will strain her relationship with Cal, requiring “a few conversations” to rebuild trust. Liam’s presence could force Maggie to confront her past, especially if their marriage was a youthful mistake rather than a lasting bond. His Hallmark-star status, noted by Swooon, suggests he’ll be a charismatic antagonist, complicating Maggie’s plans without necessarily being the father.

Other Father Figures: Sully and Beyond

Beyond biological paternity, Sullivan’s Crossing emphasizes chosen family, with Sully and others potentially stepping into father-figure roles for Maggie’s child. Sully, Maggie’s estranged father, has been a central figure in her journey, with their reconciliation a key arc. His decision to travel to Ireland with Helen (Kate Vernon) in Season 3 leaves Maggie and Cal in charge of the campground, but his promise to return suggests he’ll remain a presence. Sully’s bond with Lola (Amalia Williamson), whom he treated as a daughter figure, shows his capacity for nurturing, which could extend to Maggie’s child.

Other characters, like Frank Cranebear (Tom Jackson), who has been a fatherly figure to Maggie, could also play a role. Frank and Edna’s recovery from her brain tumor surgery, performed by Maggie, strengthened their bond, making Frank a potential grandfatherly figure. The show’s focus on community, as Roth told Collider, suggests Maggie’s child will be raised by Timberlake’s extended family, regardless of who the biological father is.

Fan Expectations and Season 4 Stakes

The October 12 premiere will likely address Maggie’s pregnancy early, given its prominence in promotional buzz. Fans on X are vocal about wanting a satisfying resolution, with @jellysavenue drawing parallels to other shows where confessions disrupt relationships, urging the writers to avoid clichés. The show’s Netflix surge since July 2025 has heightened expectations, with its Top 10 ranking fueling demand for emotional depth. Roth’s promise of “exciting and emotional challenges” for Season 4, coupled with filming in Halifax until November 2025, suggests a season packed with drama.

Maggie’s pregnancy could be a turning point, forcing her to balance her new medical practice with impending motherhood. Cal’s response—whether as the father or a supportive partner—will test their bond, especially after Liam’s revelation. The show’s history of blending romance with personal growth, as Murray noted, points to a resolution where Maggie and Cal confront their pasts to build a future.

Why It Matters

Maggie’s pregnancy confession in Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4 is more than a plot twist; it’s a chance to explore themes of trust, family, and resilience. Whether Cal, Liam, or another figure steps up, the revelation will reshape Timberlake’s dynamics. As fans await October 12, the promise of a cozy yet chaotic season, set against Nova Scotia’s stunning backdrop, ensures Sullivan’s Crossing will remain a must-watch. Tune in to see if Maggie’s baby brings her and Cal closer—or tears them apart.

Sources: Collider, Swooon, Netflix Tudum, Us Weekly, Deadline, People