SIRENS Season 2 Is Coming — A Forbidden Kiss Between Devon and Johnny Splits the Fandom!

Netflix’s Sirens is gearing up for its highly anticipated Season 2 premiere on November 3, 2025, and the fandom is already in a frenzy over a bombshell teaser: a forbidden kiss between Devon DeWitt (Meghann Fahy) and new character Johnny (Jacob Elordi). This unexpected romantic twist, layered atop the show’s signature blend of dark comedy, class warfare, and psychological drama, has divided fans into passionate camps. With Season 1’s shocking betrayal between Devon, Simone (Milly Alcock), and Michaela (Julianne Moore) setting the stage, this kiss promises to ignite new tensions and reshape the narrative. Here’s a deep dive into why this moment is breaking the Sirens fandom in half, what it means for Season 2, and how it fits into the show’s complex tapestry.

Season 1 Recap: A Tangled Web of Betrayal

Sirens Season 1, adapted from Molly Smith Metzler’s 2011 play Elemeno Pea, captivated audiences with its five-episode arc set over a Labor Day weekend in the fictional Port Haven, New England. The story centered on sisters Devon and Simone DeWitt, whose strained relationship was tested by the seductive world of billionaire socialite Michaela “Kiki” Kell (Julianne Moore). Devon, a semi-functioning alcoholic caring for their dementia-stricken father, Bruce, arrived at Michaela’s lavish Cliff House estate to reconnect with Simone, who had abandoned her legal career to become Michaela’s live-in assistant.

The season explored themes of trauma, privilege, and manipulation, with Michaela’s siren-like charisma blurring the lines between mentor and predator. Simone, enthralled by Michaela’s world, grew distant from Devon, adopting her boss’s mannerisms. The finale delivered a gut-punch: after Peter Kell (Kevin Bacon), Michaela’s husband, kissed Simone, Michaela fired her, fearing a threat to her marriage. Simone, however, betrayed Michaela by aligning with Peter, who ousted his wife from Cliff House. Simone assumed Michaela’s role, donning an elegant gown, while Devon returned to Buffalo and Michaela boarded a ferry to the mainland, her wealth and status stripped away.

The season’s 76% Rotten Tomatoes rating and praise for its “incisive commentary” (IndieWire) cemented Sirens as a must-watch. Now, Season 2’s teaser about a “forbidden kiss” between Devon and Johnny, a new character played by Jacob Elordi, has fans buzzing—and arguing—over its implications.

The Forbidden Kiss: What We Know

Netflix dropped the bombshell in a cryptic Season 2 teaser, spotlighting a “forbidden kiss” between Devon and Johnny, described only as a charismatic newcomer to Port Haven. Jacob Elordi, known for Euphoria and Saltburn, joins the cast, bringing his magnetic intensity to the role. While details about Johnny’s background are scarce, Forbes and TUDUM speculate he could be a local with ties to Port Haven’s elite, possibly a rival to Peter Kell or a figure from Michaela’s past seeking to disrupt her downfall.

The kiss is labeled “forbidden,” suggesting it crosses moral, social, or personal boundaries. Fan theories on Reddit and X propose several possibilities:

Johnny might be connected to Peter or Simone, making the kiss a betrayal of her sister or a power play against the Kells.

Devon’s kiss could be a reckless act tied to her alcoholism, complicating her arc of seeking stability.

The kiss might be forbidden due to class divides, with Johnny representing a world Devon can’t fully enter, echoing the show’s class warfare themes.

The fandom is split down the middle. One camp, dubbed “Team Kiss,” celebrates the chemistry between Fahy and Elordi, with X posts calling it “the spark Devon deserves” after Season 1’s heartbreak. They argue it could empower Devon, giving her a romantic arc to counter Simone’s rise. The other camp, “Anti-Kiss,” fears it undermines Devon’s growth, with Reddit threads warning it might “derail her redemption” or entangle her in another toxic dynamic. Some fans even speculate Johnny could be a manipulator, drawing parallels to Michaela’s siren-like influence.

Why the Kiss Is Dividing Fans

The kiss’s polarizing impact stems from Sirens’ nuanced portrayal of Devon. In Season 1, her struggle with alcoholism and resentment toward Simone’s ambition made her both relatable and flawed. Meghann Fahy told Variety that Devon’s arc was about “finding her footing” while grappling with family trauma, including their mother’s suicide attempt. Fans rooting for Devon’s healing worry the kiss with Johnny—especially if forbidden due to ulterior motives—could push her back into chaos. As one X user posted, “Devon deserves love, not another mistake.”

Conversely, Team Kiss sees the moment as a chance for Devon to reclaim agency. Her Season 1 dynamic with Simone was marked by toxic co-dependency, with Devon demanding Simone share her misery (Hollywood Reporter). A romantic connection with Johnny could signal growth, especially if it challenges her self-destructive patterns. Elordi’s casting adds fuel, with his heartthrob status sparking excitement about a steamy, transformative arc. “Fahy and Elordi together? I’m seated,” one X fan tweeted.

The “forbidden” label also ties into the show’s siren metaphor, where desire often leads to danger. As Metzler told ScreenRant, the characters are both “luring others in” and “drawn to pain.” If Johnny is tied to the Kells’ world, the kiss could pull Devon into the same cycle of ambition and betrayal that ensnared Simone, deepening the sisters’ rift.

How the Kiss Fits Into Season 2

The kiss is likely a catalyst for the “shocking betrayal” teased between Devon, Simone, and Michaela. Several scenarios could unfold:

Devon’s Betrayal: If Johnny is linked to Peter or Simone, the kiss could be seen as Devon undermining her sister’s new status. Simone, now Peter’s partner, might view it as a personal attack, escalating their feud.

Johnny’s Motive: Johnny could be a wildcard, manipulating Devon to destabilize Simone or Michaela. His charm, per TUDUM, might mirror Michaela’s, making Devon vulnerable to his influence.

Simone’s Reaction: Simone’s Season 1 betrayal of Michaela showed her willingness to prioritize power. If she perceives the kiss as a threat, she might retaliate, perhaps exposing Devon’s vulnerabilities to Peter’s elite circle.

The kiss also ties into Season 2’s rumored darker tone, with Reddit leaks suggesting one sister may not survive the season. If Devon’s kiss with Johnny leads to reckless choices, it could exacerbate her alcoholism, aligning with the “unexpected” cause of death hinted by insiders (Forbes). Alternatively, if Simone feels betrayed, her actions could indirectly harm Devon, echoing their childhood trauma.

What to Expect in Season 2

Season 2, premiering November 3, 2025, will likely retain Sirens’ hallucinatory visuals and biting humor, with Port Haven’s opulent setting amplifying the stakes. The cast, including Kevin Bacon, Glenn Howerton, and Josh Segarra, will be joined by Elordi, with Epicdope.com hinting at other new faces. Costume design will play a key role, with Devon’s gritty style contrasting Johnny’s polished aesthetic, per TUDUM.

Key plot points to watch:

Simone’s life as Peter’s partner and whether she adopts Michaela’s controlling traits (Forbes).

Michaela’s fight for redemption, possibly through a legal battle against Peter (RadioTimes.com).

Devon’s struggle with sobriety and whether the kiss with Johnny empowers or derails her (Variety).

The betrayal’s fallout, potentially leading to the rumored death of a sister.

Why It Matters

The forbidden kiss between Devon and Johnny has split the Sirens fandom because it strikes at the heart of the show’s themes: desire, power, and the cost of betrayal. Whether it’s a step toward Devon’s liberation or a trap pulling her deeper into Port Haven’s web, the moment promises to redefine her arc and the sisters’ dynamic. As Sirens Season 2 approaches, fans are bracing for a season of heartbreak, intrigue, and siren songs that refuse to fade. Will Devon’s kiss spark a new beginning or seal her fate? Only November 3 will tell.