Sirens Season 2: A Forbidden Romance and a Shocking Twist for Devon

Netflix’s Sirens, a dark comedy that captivated audiences with its May 22, 2025 premiere, has left fans clamoring for more after its explosive five-episode run. Starring Meghann Fahy as Devon DeWitt, Milly Alcock as Simone DeWitt, and Julianne Moore as the magnetic Michaela “Kiki” Kell, the series—based on Molly Smith Metzler’s play Elemeno Pea—delivered a twisted tale of power, betrayal, and class warfare. Though labeled a limited series, its 16.7 million views in four days and cryptic comments from the cast have fueled speculation about a second season. A tantalizing rumor suggests Season 2 could introduce a forbidden romance between Simone and Michaela’s estranged heir, with a twist that “Devon won’t see coming.” Here’s what a hypothetical Season 2 might hold.

Season 1’s Aftermath: A Fractured Trio

Season 1, set over a Labor Day weekend in the fictional Port Haven, saw sisters Devon and Simone clash over Simone’s devotion to Michaela, a billionaire socialite married to Peter Kell (Kevin Bacon). Devon’s mission to “rescue” Simone from Michaela’s cult-like influence unraveled when Simone betrayed her mentor, aligning with Peter to oust Michaela and claim his wealth. The finale left Simone as the new Mrs. Kell, Devon returning to Buffalo to care for their ailing father, and Michaela boarding a ferry to an uncertain future. The series’ exploration of trauma, ambition, and female dynamics, paired with its pastel-soaked aesthetic, earned it a 77% on Rotten Tomatoes.

A Forbidden Romance in Season 2?

A speculative Season 2 could introduce a new character: Michaela’s estranged heir, perhaps a child from a previous relationship or a long-lost relative tied to her Fresno roots. Let’s call this character Lena, a fiercely independent woman in her late 20s who arrives in Port Haven to claim her stake in the Kell legacy. Lena’s presence would threaten Simone’s precarious position as Peter’s wife, igniting a charged, forbidden romance between the two women. Their chemistry—fueled by shared ambition and mutual distrust—could echo the unsettling dynamic between Simone and Michaela in Season 1, but with a romantic edge. Posts on X have hinted at fan interest in a sapphic storyline, amplifying speculation about such a plot.

This romance would be forbidden not only due to Lena’s claim to the Kell fortune but also because Simone’s marriage to Peter ties her to the very empire Lena seeks to dismantle. Their clandestine encounters—perhaps in Michaela’s abandoned aviary or on the cliffs of Cliff House—would test Simone’s loyalty to her new life and force her to confront her self-destructive tendencies, a theme central to Season 1.

“Devon Won’t See It Coming”

The twist that “Devon won’t see coming” could involve her unexpected return to Port Haven, drawn by rumors of Simone’s unraveling marriage. Devon, now settled in Buffalo with a job and therapy to manage her alcoholism, might arrive expecting to save her sister again, only to discover Simone’s affair with Lena. The shock would stem from Devon’s realization that Simone’s betrayal extends beyond Michaela to Peter—and that Devon’s own bond with Michaela, forged on the ferry in Season 1, puts her at odds with Lena. This could lead to a heartbreaking confrontation where Devon, grappling with her role as the “savior” sister, must choose between protecting Simone or letting her face the consequences.

Michaela’s Return and New Stakes

Julianne Moore’s Michaela would likely return, her “reptilian calculation” (as described by IndieWire) driving a revenge plot against Simone and Peter. Her connection to Lena could complicate matters—perhaps Lena is the daughter Michaela never had, a nod to her childlessness that ended her marriage. The trio of Fahy, Alcock, and Moore would shine again, their performances anchoring a season that delves deeper into class, identity, and forbidden desire.

What’s Next for Sirens?

While Netflix has not confirmed Season 2, Molly Smith Metzler’s comment to Glamour—“I could write them until the day I die”—and Milly Alcock’s enthusiasm for exploring Simone’s arc suggest potential for more. A forbidden romance between Simone and Lena, coupled with a twist that blindsides Devon, would keep Sirens’ signature mix of camp, drama, and social commentary alive. Until Netflix announces a renewal, fans can stream Season 1 and speculate about the next chapter in Port Haven’s seductive saga.