Spoiler alert: We’re about to break down the jaw-dropping final moments of Ginny & Georgia Season 3. Haven’t finished bingeing? You’ve been warned.

Let’s hope we don’t have to wait another 29 months for Ginny & Georgia to return for its fourth season, because the Netflix drama just left us on the mother of all cliffhangers.

Now streaming, the 10-episode third season ends with a jury finding Georgia not guilty of killing Tom, thanks to Ginny convincing Austin to lie on the stand about seeing Gil commit the brutal act. But it’s not like Georgia’s freedom comes without a price; after enduring one too many of his wife’s lies, including Georgia attempting to pass off Ginny’s positive pregnancy test as her own, Paul finally asks for a divorce.

Georgia has a lot to process by the end of the finale, and nothing helps a girl clear her head quite like downing milk straight from the bottle. Instead of letting her mom chug all that sweet, sweet vitamin D in peace, however, Ginny interjects with a game-changing question: “Didn’t you say you drink milk when you’re pregnant?”

That’s right, folks, Georgia is confirmed to be with child. And to complicate matters even further, we’re not sure who the father is! Yes, she was married to Paul, but she and Joe also recently found themselves in bed together, setting the stage for a major paternity reveal in Season 4.

 

So, who is Georgia’s third baby daddy? The powers that be aren’t ready to reveal that just yet. In fact, showrunner Sarah Glinski tells Entertainment Weekly that the mystery will likely be stretched out for quite some time.

According to series creator Sarah Lampert, she and Glinski opened the Season 4 writers’ room by telling the staff, “OK, we know whose baby it is. Change our mind.” What followed was a “contentious,” full-day debate amongst the writers. “There was a debate over how the storylines could go based on whose baby it was and all that,” Lampert says. “But no, we’ve landed on whose baby it is. I’ll say that.”

Since Lampert and Glinski won’t spill the beans, that leaves us to do what fans do best — wildly speculate! And in the case of Georgia’s pregnancy, there are really two questions we must ask ourselves: who do we think it is, and who do we hope it is? Grade Ginny & Georgia Season 3 in our poll below, then drop a comment with your thoughts about this particular cliffhanger.