Andi Peters’ Brutal Swipe at Josie Gibson on This Morning Sparks Laughter and Debate
On April 21, 2025, ITV’s This Morning took an unexpected turn when veteran presenter Andi Peters left co-host Josie Gibson speechless with a cheeky comment about her appearance during a live broadcast. The quip, delivered during a light-hearted segment about herbal teas, sent the studio into fits of laughter but also ignited a firestorm of reactions online. Described as a “brutal swipe” by media outlets, the moment has become a viral talking point, raising questions about on-air banter, workplace dynamics, and the fine line between humor and offense. This article delves into the incident, its context within This Morning’s recent presenter shake-ups, and the broader implications of such moments in live television.
The Incident: A Cheeky Comment Goes Viral
The episode began like any other, with Andi Peters, 54, and Josie Gibson, 40, returning from an advert break to introduce a segment on the health benefits of herbal teas. Peters, known for his quick wit and playful demeanor, was co-hosting in place of regular presenters Cat Deeley and Ben Shephard, who were on a break due to the Easter holidays. Gibson, a beloved figure since her Big Brother win in 2010, was equally at ease, having stepped in for Alison Hammond in recent weeks. The pair’s chemistry promised a lively show, but no one anticipated the moment that would dominate headlines.
+6
View gallery
Andi Peters left his This Morning co-host Josie Gibson open-mouthed with BRUTAL swipe at her face live on Monday’s instalment of the ITV show
+6
View gallery
Andi’s comment left his co-host in shock with her mouth wide open – and the camera crew laughed a long in the background
As they transitioned to the tea segment, Peters made an impromptu remark about Gibson’s face, reportedly referencing her makeup or expression in a way that caught her off guard. While the exact wording remains debated—ITV has not released a full transcript—witnesses described it as a “cheeky swipe” that left Gibson momentarily open-mouthed. The studio erupted in laughter, with crew members and guests, including Loose Women’s Jane Moore, joining in. Gibson, ever the professional, quickly recovered, playfully swatting at Peters and steering the conversation back to the topic at hand. The moment was brief but electric, capturing the unpredictable energy of live television.
Social media exploded with reactions. On X, fans shared clips of the exchange, with one user writing, “Andi Peters just roasted Josie on #ThisMorning and I’m living for it 😂.” Another posted, “Josie’s face when Andi said that—priceless! But was it too far?” The incident also drew criticism, with some viewers calling the comment “unprofessional” and “mean-spirited.” One X user remarked, “Andi needs to chill with the jabs. Josie didn’t deserve that on live TV.” The polarized responses highlight the divisive nature of on-air banter, particularly when it targets a co-host’s appearance.
Context: Andi Peters’ Controversial Week
The swipe at Gibson was not Peters’ only headline-grabbing moment that week. Earlier, he had sparked chaos on This Morning with a risqué sex joke during an interview, leaving Gibson “squirming” and prompting viewer backlash. The Scottish Sun reported that Peters’ comment, made during a light-hearted segment, was deemed inappropriate for daytime television, with fans on X pleading for him to “calm down” and accusing him of “hogging” the show. One viewer wrote, “Love Josie but Andi Peters should stick to competitions—he’s horrific as a host.” Another added, “Andi’s trying too hard to be edgy. It’s not working.”
Peters, a fixture on ITV for over a decade, is no stranger to controversy. Known for hosting competition segments across Good Morning Britain, This Morning, Lorraine, and Loose Women, he has faced criticism for his global travels to promote these contests. In February 2025, viewers slammed his trip to Cape Town as “unnecessary,” accusing ITV of “top-quality gaslighting” for touting sustainability while funding such flights. A similar outcry followed his April broadcast from Florida, with X users decrying his “freebie holiday” to promote a Walt Disney World competition. One post read, “Stop flying Andi Peters around the world for £2 entry scams!”
Despite the backlash, Peters remains a polarizing yet enduring presence. His emotional moments, like fighting back tears during a Good Morning Britain segment about a mother’s loss, reveal a softer side that contrasts with his brash humor. On January 7, 2025, he was visibly moved while reporting from Edinburgh, admitting, “Slightly moved, I can’t lie,” after a harrowing interview. Such moments underscore his versatility, even as his cheeky style courts controversy.
+6
View gallery
Concerned This Morning fans ask ‘have they got rid of him?!’ as ITV host disappears from show without explanation – and is replaced with controversial stand-in
+6
View gallery
Andi Peters and Josie Gibson (pictured) presented the ITV show on Monday – which left some fans worried about another presenter
+6
View gallery
Some viewers took to X, formerly known as Twitter, to share their worry over the fact they haven’t seen Craig Doyle in a while
Josie Gibson: A Fan Favorite Under Pressure
Josie Gibson, meanwhile, has navigated her own challenges. Since joining This Morning in 2018 as a competition presenter and later becoming a stand-in host, she has won over audiences with her warmth and relatability. Her recent stint replacing Alison Hammond, who was absent for unspecified reasons, earned praise, with one X user noting, “Josie’s a breath of fresh air on #ThisMorning. Love her energy.” However, her return has not been without hurdles. In February 2025, Gibson presented the show on crutches after a “nightmare” holiday injury in Dubai, where a bathroom vanity unit fell on her foot, leaving her in “excruciating pain.”
The injury, which forced her to spend her vacation in a wheelchair, became a talking point when co-host Alison Hammond gifted her a customized mobility scooter on air, complete with a “Gibson” number plate. The gesture highlighted the camaraderie among the This Morning team, but it also underscored Gibson’s resilience in performing under physical strain. Her ability to laugh off Peters’ swipe further demonstrates her professionalism, though some fans worried the comment added unnecessary pressure. One X post read, “Josie’s been through enough with her injury. Andi’s joke was out of line.”
+6
View gallery
Cat Deeley and Ben Shephard, who are currently on a break from the show, present the ITV show Monday to Thursday
The Dynamics of Live TV Banter
The Peters-Gibson incident reflects the high-stakes nature of live television, where spontaneity can lead to both viral moments and missteps. On-air banter is a hallmark of shows like This Morning, designed to create a relaxed, conversational vibe. However, when humor targets personal attributes, it risks crossing into discomfort, especially under the scrutiny of millions. Peters’ history of playful jabs—such as his March 2025 swipe at Susanna Reid’s outfit on Good Morning Britain, comparing it to “napkins”—suggests a pattern of pushing boundaries. Reid, like Gibson, laughed it off, but the recurrence of such moments raises questions about intent and impact.
Gender dynamics also play a role. Female presenters like Gibson and Reid often face heightened scrutiny over their appearance, with comments about their looks drawing disproportionate attention. Peters’ swipe at Gibson’s face, while framed as humor, echoes past incidents where female hosts bore the brunt of on-air critiques. For instance, Good Morning Britain’s Ranvir Singh faced backlash for an ill-fitting blazer during Pope Francis’s death announcement, a wardrobe choice that overshadowed her delivery of major news. Such parallels highlight the uneven expectations placed on women in media.
Viewer Reactions and Media Amplification
The viral nature of the Peters-Gibson moment owes much to media amplification. Outlets like the Daily Mail and The Scottish Sun framed the swipe as “brutal” and “cheeky,” fueling online debate. The Daily Mail reported that the studio “erupted into laughter,” while The Sun emphasized Gibson’s “squirming” reaction to Peters’ earlier sex joke, painting a picture of a show teetering on chaos. These headlines, while attention-grabbing, may exaggerate the incident’s severity, as the laughter suggests a shared understanding among the hosts.
X posts further amplified the moment, with clips circulating widely. The platform’s real-time nature allowed fans to dissect the exchange, with some praising Peters’ humor and others defending Gibson. One user wrote, “Andi and Josie’s chemistry is gold, but that face comment was a bit much.” Another countered, “Josie took it like a champ. People need to lighten up.” The split sentiment reflects broader cultural debates about humor in professional settings, particularly when it risks undermining a colleague.
The Bigger Picture: This Morning’s Turbulent Year
The incident comes amid a turbulent period for This Morning. The show has faced presenter shake-ups, with Alison Hammond’s unexplained absences and Cat Deeley and Ben Shephard’s holiday breaks prompting frequent stand-ins. Gibson’s increased presence has been a bright spot, but Peters’ controversial moments have drawn scrutiny. Viewer complaints about his competition segments, coupled with criticism of his hosting style, suggest ITV may need to reassess his role. Meanwhile, the show’s history of behind-the-scenes tensions—such as the 2019 feud between Ruth Langsford and Phillip Schofield—underscores the challenges of maintaining harmony on a high-profile program.
Conclusion: A Moment of Humor or a Misstep?
Andi Peters’ swipe at Josie Gibson was a fleeting moment that encapsulated the unpredictable charm of This Morning. For some, it was a hilarious example of the show’s playful spirit; for others, it was an uncomfortable overstep that highlighted the pitfalls of live banter. Gibson’s quick recovery and the studio’s laughter suggest the comment was not malicious, but the public’s divided reaction underscores the delicate balance of humor in broadcasting. As This Morning navigates its evolving lineup and viewer expectations, such moments serve as both entertainment and cautionary tales, reminding us of the human dynamics at play behind the polished veneer of daytime TV.
