Helen Baxendale’s Emily was written off FRIENDS as she wasn’t able to be as funny as David Schwimmer and didn’t meet the standard Rachel set.

Over the course of its 10 seasons, FRIENDS introduced many interesting love interests for fans to judge. They were funny, and weird, and even brought out feelings of concern among fans. However, some love interests were simply irritating and infuriating for many viewers. While some would immediately think of Chandler’s ex-girlfriend, Janis, there was one character that managed to annoy fans more than the singing queen.

Ross’s ex-wife, Emily Waltham brought about an energy into the show that no fan wanted. She shifted the dynamic between all of the characters, acting as a catalyst for the beloved Ross and Rachel. While no one wanted her to stay longer than she did, fans cannot help but wonder the reason why the series decided to write her off.
Helen Baxendale as Emily on FRIENDS I NBC
According to director, James Burrows, it would seem that Jennifer Aniston and her character had a lot to do with the decision.

Why did Emily Leave FRIENDS?

Even though a majority of fans disliked the character of Emily Waltham in FRIENDS, they have been curious about the exact reason why she was removed from the series. TV director, James Burrows detailed in his memoir, Directed by James Burrows, exactly why he decided to write her off. It would seem that even though the character was dislikable, there was one very big reason why they decided that they were better off without her; humor.

Helen Baxendale as Emily on FRIENDS I NBC
The director revealed that there was chemistry and a love of connection between her character and Ross, as well as Helen Baxendale and David Schwimmer. However, the actress was simply not able to keep up with the humor aspect of the show. Ross could easily be one of the funniest characters in the series, and they very quickly realized that Emily was simply not able to do the same.

She was nice, but not particularly funny. Schwimmer had no one to bounce off. It was like clapping with one hand. 

David Schwimmer as Ross in FRIENDS I NBC
Even though the showrunners made several attempts, considering how she got plenty of time on the show, according to Burrows, Schwimmer was trying to make it work on his own.

Rachel Green Set A New Standard For Ross Geller

James Burrows then went on to talk about what makes romantic interests stay in sitcoms. While chemistry is certainly very important, humor is one of the biggest aspects of shows like FRIENDS. With this in mind, having a character that was eliciting feelings of anger and annoyance from fans and not even a single laugh simply did not work in the show’s favor.
Ross and Rachel from FRIENDS I NBC
Burrows then went on to reveal quite an interesting lesson that the show learned after Emily’s exit. Even though both Ross and Rachel have several love interests throughout the series, it was evidently clear that the writer was going to make them get together by the end of the show. While this was the case, they could not make it very obvious.

In sitcoms and any type of romantic comedy, the funny is just as important as the chemistry. We discovered that any new girlfriend for Ross needed to be as funny as Rachel.

David Schwimmer and Jennifer Aniston as Ross and Rachel in FRIENDS I NBC
With this in mind, they could not bring in love interests for Ross, who was less funny than Jennifer Aniston’s character. They needed someone who some fans could root for and not boo the moment that they showed up on screen.

Due to this, they decided to make sure that every new love interest that David Schwimmer’s character was getting met the standard set by Rachel Green.

 

FRIENDS is available for streaming on Netflix.