Mystery Deepens in Brutal Slaying of Ohio Dentist Spencer Tepe and Wife Monique: Eerie Surveillance Footage Reveals Shadowy Figure – But Rumors of Ex-Husband Link Remain Unsubstantiated

One week after the shocking double homicide of beloved Columbus couple Spencer Tepe, 37, and Monique Tepe, 39, investigators remain tight-lipped on suspects or motive, even as newly released surveillance video has ignited public speculation. The grainy footage, captured in the early hours of December 30, 2025, shows a hooded “person of interest” trudging through a snowy alley near the family’s Weinland Park home – baffling police and fueling online theories about who could have committed such a targeted, execution-style killing.

people.com

people.com

foxnews.com

newschannel9.com

people.com

abc6onyourside.com

Spencer, a respected dentist at Athens Dental Depot, and Monique, a devoted stay-at-home mother with a background in childhood education, were found shot to death on the second floor of their North 4th Street home – the very place where they exchanged vows in an intimate 2021 ceremony just months before their fifth anniversary. Their two young children, aged 4 and 1, along with the family Goldendoodle, were unharmed inside the house, a detail that has only added to the chilling mystery.

dispatch.com

people.com

ctvnews.ca

people.com

The discovery came after a frantic welfare check on December 30. Spencer, known for his reliability, failed to show up for work – uncharacteristic for the Ohio State University graduate and avid Cincinnati Bengals fan. Coworkers, including practice owner Dr. Mark Valrose, grew alarmed when neither Spencer nor Monique answered calls. A friend arrived at the home, heard the children crying inside, and called 911. Police found the couple deceased from multiple gunshot wounds: Spencer shot several times, Monique at least once in the chest. No weapon was recovered, no signs of forced entry, and authorities quickly ruled out murder-suicide.

Columbus Police believe the killings occurred between 2 a.m. and 5 a.m. On January 5, 2026, they released the surveillance clip showing the mysterious figure – dressed in light-colored pants, a dark hooded jacket, head down, hands in pockets – walking slowly in the alley behind the Tepes’ garage during that exact window. “Detectives believe the murder… occurred sometime between 2:00 and 5:00 a.m…. Recovered video footage shows a person of interest walking in the alley near the residence during that timeframe,” police stated. The footage, described as “eerie” and “chilling,” has prompted hundreds of tips, but no arrests.

The community has been left reeling. Weinland Park, a revitalized neighborhood near downtown Columbus, now feels shadowed by fear. A growing memorial of flowers, candles, and personal mementos has formed on the couple’s porch, a poignant tribute to lives cut short.

abc6onyourside.com

abc6onyourside.com

dispatch.com

people.com

people.com

Family statements paint a picture of profound loss. “Our family is devastated by the tragic and senseless loss of Spencer and Monique,” they said. “They were extraordinary people whose lives were filled with love, joy, and deep connection to others.” Spencer was remembered as energetic, generous, fluent in Spanish, and involved with Big Brothers Big Sisters. Monique as warm, patient, an excellent baker who lit up every room. A GoFundMe for their orphaned children has raised over $170,000, reflecting widespread grief.

Amid the speculation, unverified rumors have circulated online – including claims from alleged “close friends” that Monique’s ex-husband was seen loitering outside the home a week prior. However, major outlets like CNN, Fox News, People, and The Columbus Dispatch report no confirmed suspects, no mention of an ex-husband’s involvement, and no prior surveillance linking anyone specific. Police have not addressed these whispers, urging the public to focus on verified tips via Central Ohio Crime Stoppers.

Experts note the lack of forced entry suggests the killer may have been known to the couple or gained access another way. No items appear stolen, pointing to a possible targeted attack. The children, now with relatives, add heartbreaking urgency – family members grapple with how to explain the tragedy to the 4-year-old daughter.

As the investigation continues, Columbus Police seek additional footage from the area and urge anyone recognizing the person of interest to come forward. The shadowy figure in the snow has become the focal point, but the full story behind this senseless crime remains elusive. For a community mourning two pillars of kindness, justice can’t come soon enough.