Gloves found near Nancy Guthrie’s home belonged to restaurant worker, have no connection to the case
DNA from gloves found about 2 miles away from Nancy Gunthrie’s Arizona home was traced back to a local restaurant worker who has no connection to the investigation, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department said Wednesday.
“Sheriff [Chris] Nanos stated in a recent interview that the black gloves found approximately 2 miles away from Nancy Guthrie’s home were traced back via DNA analysis to a person who works at a restaurant in the area. That person is not considered part of this investigation,” a department spokesperson told CBS News in a statement. “Lab analysis remains underway on other DNA evidence.”

A black glove was found near Nancy Guthrie’s home on Feb. 11, and days later, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department said a DNA profile from the gloves that were submitted to a national database maintained by the FBI didn’t come back with any matches. The FBI said at the time that the suspect seen in the doorbell camera video appeared to be wearing similar gloves.
The DNA profile had been submitted to the database known as CoDIS, or Combined DNA Index System, the sheriff’s department said. The national database maintained by the FBI could have provided a match if the individual had a previous arrest for certain crimes and supplied a DNA sample that put him into the system.
The glove was found in a field near a roadside and was one of approximately 16 gloves collected by investigators in various areas near the house, but most of those other gloves belonged to searchers who discarded them while working the area, the FBI has said.
Nancy Guthrie, the mother of “Today” show co-host Savannah Guthrie, was first reported missing on Feb. 1, sparking a massive search effort for the 84-year-old.
The sheriff’s department has also sent DNA evidence from the scene to a private lab in Florida, rather than the FBI’s lab in Quantico, Virginia. Nanos told CBS News at the time that his agency has been sending evidence to the Florida lab for years, and he doesn’t want samples sent to two different facilities. The sheriff has said he’s hopeful that the DNA will lead to a name.
DNA recovered from Nancy Guthrie’s home may not yield a usable profile of the suspect, according to sources close to the investigation, with one source calling it “low-level.”
Nancy Guthrie’s family offered a reward of up to $1 million for information leading to her recovery. The FBI is also offering a reward of $100,000.
News
💔 FRIEND REVEAL: A longtime friend of Thy Mitchell told investigators she recently spoke about “starting over slowly,” while police noted a packed overnight bag containing children’s clothing was recovered near the staircase landing
The River Oaks murder-suicide that claimed the lives of Thy Mitchell, 39, her children Maya, 8, and Max, 4, and their unborn baby has continued to yield devastating new details. What began as a shocking discovery of four bodies in…
🚨 ONE DETAIL CHANGED EVERYTHING: Authorities investigating Matthew Mitchell documented a nursery planning checklist partially hidden beneath business paperwork, with three items crossed out in black marker and one line left unfinished
In the meticulous investigation into the River Oaks murder-suicide that claimed the lives of Thy Mitchell, her two young children, and their unborn baby, one seemingly innocuous discovery has altered the emotional landscape of the case. Tucked beneath stacks of…
Nothing looked wrong online: Friends now say Thy Mitchell continued posting family content just days before the tragedy, but detectives reportedly recovered multiple unsent notes from her phone saved between 1:11 AM and 3:04 AM during the final week
In the curated glow of Instagram and Facebook, the Mitchell family of River Oaks appeared to embody the Houston dream. Vibrant photos of smiling children at the family restaurant, elegant date-night snapshots from Traveler’s Table in Montrose, and glowing pregnancy…
THE INTERVIEW ROOM WENT SILENT — Investigators questioning William Graham Oliver reportedly confronted him with new evidence tied to Lisa Gail Fields’s household… and the transcript shows a full page containing only one short answer followed by several blank lines
The interrogation of 54-year-old William Graham Oliver in the Wilmer, Alabama quadruple homicide case took a dramatic turn, according to sources close to the investigation. When detectives presented fresh evidence linked directly to victim Lisa Gail Fields and her household,…
A RELATIVE CHANGED THEIR STORY — Sources close to the investigation say one person connected to Keziah Luker gave detectives updated information after the arrest of William Graham Oliver… and the revised statement includes a newly added paragraph attached with a staple to the original report
The Wilmer, Alabama quadruple homicide investigation has taken another intriguing turn as new details emerge about witness statements following the arrest of 54-year-old William Graham Oliver. Sources familiar with the case indicate that at least one relative or close associate…
THE MOTIVE QUESTION JUST GOT BIGGER — Authorities confirmed William Graham Oliver knew the family before the incident in Wilmer, Alabama… and investigators later recovered a handwritten page mentioning money and don’t come back here again from inside the residence
The Wilmer, Alabama quadruple homicide case continues to reveal layers of personal connection and potential prior tension between suspect William Graham Oliver and the victims. What began as a possible random or burglary-related attack has evolved into a deeper investigation…
End of content
No more pages to load