Jesse Watters’ “Shocking” Gift to Greg Gutfeld After the News of His Second Child – And Gutfeld’s Reaction Made Everyone Laugh

Jesse Watters and Greg Gutfeld, two of Fox News’ most dynamic personalities, have long entertained audiences with their playful banter on The Five and their respective shows, Jesse Watters Primetime and Gutfeld!. At 46 and 60, respectively, their on-air rivalry is a mix of sharp jabs and genuine camaraderie. So, when Watters presented Gutfeld with a “shocking” gift on a May 2025 episode of The Five to celebrate the news of Gutfeld’s second child, expected later in 2025, the studio erupted in laughter. Gutfeld’s priceless reaction, a blend of mock horror and quick-witted retort, stole the show, cementing another memorable moment in their storied friendship and delighting fans across the internet.

A Friendship Fueled by Humor

Watters, born in Philadelphia in 1978, rose to prominence as a Fox News host, taking over the 8 p.m. slot with Jesse Watters Primetime in 2023, while Gutfeld, born in San Francisco in 1964, has been a Fox News staple since launching Gutfeld! in 2015. Their chemistry on The Five, where they co-host alongside Dana Perino, Jeanine Pirro, and Jessica Tarlov, is marked by playful feuds, like Gutfeld’s 2024 trolling of Watters’ book, Get It Together, for outranking “The Anarchist Cookbook” on Amazon’s radical political thought list.

Gutfeld’s personal life took center stage with the birth of his first child, Mira, in December 2024, with his wife, Elena Moussa, 42, as noted in The US Sun. The announcement of a second child, Leo Alexander, expected in late 2025, was shared in a prior conversation memory, sparking excitement among fans. Watters, a father of four, including his daughter Georgina “Gigi” born in 2023, has often teased Gutfeld about fatherhood, joking about Mira questioning his toupee in a 2024 The Five segment. The news of Leo’s impending arrival provided Watters with fresh material for a gift that would both shock and amuse.

The Shocking Gift Unveiled

On May 19, 2025, during a lively The Five segment discussing current events, Watters interrupted the banter with a mischievous grin. “Hold up, I’ve got something for Greg,” he said, pulling a brightly wrapped box from under the desk. “This is for Leo, your second kid—congrats, old man!” The studio audience chuckled, and Gutfeld, raising an eyebrow, quipped, “Jesse, if it’s a toupee for the baby, I’m sending it back.” The box, adorned with cartoon storks and a bow, hinted at a gag, with X posts buzzing: “Watters got Gutfeld a gift for Leo? This is gonna be good!” and “What’s in that box? Greg’s face says trouble!”

As Gutfeld unwrapped the gift, Watters leaned back, smirking, “You’re gonna love this, trust me.” Inside was a custom-made baby onesie, emblazoned with “Future Primetime Star” in bold letters, and a miniature replica of Watters’ Jesse Watters Primetime microphone, complete with a tiny Fox News logo. The pièce de résistance? A framed certificate declaring Leo Alexander Gutfeld an “Honorary Watters Intern,” with a note: “Training starts at age 2!” The studio burst into laughter, with Perino gasping, “Jesse, you didn’t!” and Pirro cackling, “That’s the most Watters thing ever!”

Gutfeld’s Hilarious Reaction

Gutfeld’s reaction was pure comedy gold, leaving everyone in stitches. Holding up the onesie, he feigned outrage, “Jesse, you’re trying to poach my kid before he’s born? This is low, even for you!” He waved the microphone, adding, “What’s next, a contract for Leo to co-host Primetime? Elena’s gonna have words!” Turning to the camera, he deadpanned, “Folks, my son’s first word won’t be ‘Mama’—it’ll be ‘Ratings!’ Thanks, Watters.” The audience roared, and Timpf, guest-hosting, chimed in, “Greg, Leo’s already got better hair than Jesse’s toupee!” The jab, referencing Mira’s toupee joke, sent Watters into mock indignation, shouting, “My hair’s real, and Leo knows it!”

Gutfeld’s quick-witted retort escalated when he read the intern certificate aloud, pausing for effect. “An intern? Jesse, Leo’s not fetching your coffee—he’s running Gutfeld! by age 5!” He tossed the frame back to Watters, saying, “I’m framing this for Elena to use as a dartboard!” The studio dissolved into laughter, with Baier, in the audience, clapping, and X posts exploding: “Gutfeld’s reaction to Watters’ gift? Comedy gold!” and “Leo as a Watters intern? I’m dying!” Fans praised the duo’s chemistry, with one writing, “Greg and Jesse’s banter is why The Five rules!”

The Deeper Meaning and Context

The gift, while hilarious, carried a playful nod to their on-air rivalry and mutual respect. Watters’ choice of a Primetime-themed onesie and microphone reflected his pride in his show’s success, averaging 2.74 million viewers in its first year, as noted in Newsweek. The intern certificate was a tongue-in-cheek jab at Gutfeld’s own rise, from Red Eye to Gutfeld!, the highest-rated late-night show, as per Yahoo. The humor echoed their 2024 book-trolling exchange, where Gutfeld teased Watters’ bestseller status, showing their ability to rib each other while celebrating milestones.

The gift also tied to Gutfeld’s new role as a father, which he described as transformative in Fox News, saying becoming a parent at 60 taught him selflessness. Leo’s announcement, following Mira’s birth, added to the joy, with Gutfeld and Moussa preparing their $10.5 million SoHo apartment for a growing family, as reported in Yahoo. Watters’ gift, while shocking in its audacity, was a lighthearted way to welcome Leo, mirroring his congratulations for Mira in 2024, when he playfully embraced Gutfeld’s dad jokes.

Colleagues and Fan Reactions

The The Five crew amplified the moment’s hilarity. Perino, on America’s Newsroom, called the gift “classic Jesse—bold and ridiculous,” while Ingraham, on The Ingraham Angle, said, “Greg’s reaction was better than the gift!” Tyrus, a frequent Gutfeld! guest, tweeted, “Watters, you’re lucky Greg didn’t throw that mic at you!” Fans on X posted, “Jesse’s gift for Leo is peak The Five chaos!” and “Gutfeld’s intern rant had me rolling—Leo’s already a star!” Photos shared on Watters’ X, showing Gutfeld holding the onesie and microphone, captioned “Leo’s Primetime Ready,” went viral, with fans writing, “This gift is legendary—Greg’s face says it all!”

A Gift That Sparks Joy

The Mar-A-Lago wedding, with Watters’ shocking gift and Gutfeld’s laugh-out-loud reaction, marked another chapter in their playful rivalry. As they continue on The Five and their respective shows, their friendship, fueled by humor, inspires fans. The onesie and microphone, now displayed in Gutfeld’s nursery, symbolize their bond. “Jesse, you’re nuts, but I’ll keep the gift,” Gutfeld said, grinning. For Jesse Watters and Greg Gutfeld, this hilarious moment was more than a gift—it was a celebration of fatherhood, friendship, and a laugh that echoed far beyond the studio.