Nancy Guthrie Update: Teacher Targeted as âSuspectâ by Online Sleuths Speaks Out
Dominic Evans is in a rock band with Nancy Guthrieâs son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni. He says he was falsely accused and has nothing to do with her disappearance.
Key Points
Online sleuths falsely accused Dominic Evans in Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance due to band connection.
Evans and his family suffered harassment despite no evidence or suspicion from authorities.
âThere are innocent people that get hurt,â Evans said, describing the ordealâs impact.
Dominic Evans is a 48-year-old elementary school teacher, a father, and a drummer in a band with Tommaso Cioni, the son-in-law of missing Arizonan grandma Nancy Guthrie.
That connection made him a target of online sleuths who accused him of being a suspect in Guthrieâs disappearance. To be clear, authorities have not accused Evans or any specific person of being a suspect in Guthrieâs disappearance. Evans says he has nothing to do with Guthrieâs abduction and has been falsely accused.
My Tools Used to Be a Mess Until I Found This $42 Wall-Mounted Storage System From AmazonMy Tools Used to Be a Mess Until I Found This $42 Wall-Mounted Storage System From Amazon
Watch More
Evans spoke about the ordeal at length to The New York Times, which described how people âdescendedâ on his Tucson neighborhood, thinking Evans âmight be the man who had abducted Nancy Guthrie.â The sheriff of Pima County, Chris Nanos, previously cleared Guthrieâs kids and their spouses, including Cioni, as suspects in the case. They have also been targeted by online commentators. Guthrie vanished from her home in the early morning hours of February 1. Since that time, news outlets have received multiple ransom notes, but there has been no sign of Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of TODAY Show co-host Savannah Guthrie.
Dominic Evans Told The New York Times That âThere Are Innocent People That Get Hurtâ
NEW: I spoke with Dominic Evans, a 48-year-old schoolteacher in Tucson who plays in a band with Nancy Guthrieâs son-in-law, about how the online accusations against him have upended his and his familyâs lives this month. https://t.co/naYtgprbyw pic.twitter.com/Bb45XuuXfV
â Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs (@NickAtNews)Â February 25, 2026
The Times called what happened to Evans a âreal-life nightmare,â saying that Evans and his wife âhid in their bedroom with the lights offâ and feared they were followed.
Evans said he spoke to investigators for about 40 minutes and âhasnât heard from them since.â
âI feel like someoneâs taken my name,â Evans told The Times in an interview. But for what reasons? âI donât know â monetary, clickbait, to be relevant, entertainment â but there are innocent people that get hurt.â
The sheriff expressed empathy for Evans to The Times. âHeâs going through hell, and it is horrible,â Nanos told The Times. âAnd I donât know what to tell him except he probably should be speaking with some attorneys and sue some of these people for libel.â
Dominic Evans Belonged to a Rock Band Called Early Black With Tommaso Cioni
Evansâ link to the Guthrie family is the rock band Early Black, which he joined along with Cioni. He told The Times he met Nancy Guthrie once in 2011 when she held an Easter egg hunt at her house.
He said he learned about Guthrieâs disappearance from Instagram. He messaged Cioni to offer support, The Times reported, which added that Internet sleuths put photos of Evans alongside pictures the FBI released of the masked suspect at Guthrieâs door. That suspect has not been identified.
His wife, Andrea Evans, told The Times she was âscared numbâ by it all. Evans told The Times that sheriffâs officials asked him âabout his band, his friendship with Mr. Cioni, and his whereabouts on the night Ms. Guthrie was taken.â He told them he was at home with his family.
The Italian-born Cioni is married to Guthrieâs daughter, Annie. Sheriffâs officials have previously revealed that Annie and Cioni were the last people to see Guthrie before she was abducted, as Nancy went to dinner at their house. A family member then dropped her back off at home.
Nancy Guthrie suspect.FBI
âI was born in San Giovanni Valdarno on June 18, â75. Since 2006, I have been living in Tucson, Arizona. I write when it happens. I study lizards. I play the electric bass. I make homemade pasta,â an old bio for Cioni says.
Savannah Guthrie has announced a $1 million reward for information in the case.
News
Doctors have just released another heartbreaking update about 12-year-old Xavier Taylor, but what haunts his father even more is that the baseball bag was still unopened, and what was inside was completely intact, shocking everyone
The latest medical update from the doctors monitoring twelve-year-old Xavier Taylor has cast an even heavier shadow over a situation already defined by profound grief and national sorrow. As the medical team shared the heartbreaking reality of the young athlete’s…
The collision lasted less than a second⌠but investigators say there was a detail on the field that some parents noticed immediately afterward. Now, as Xavier Taylor fights for his life, his father says he thinks about it every night.
The collision lasted less than a second, a fleeting fragment of time that changed everything on a youth baseball field that was supposed to be filled only with the joy of summer sports. In that microscopic window, a routine play…
“You’ll wake up, won’t you…?”: As America continues praying for 12-year-old Xavier Taylor, his father has revealed a devastating update about the freak baseball accident that changed everything â but it’s the four words his son said before slipping away that he can never forget.
The story of twelve-year-old Xavier Taylor has gripped the heart of a nation, serving as a stark, devastating reminder of how quickly a joyful afternoon can transform into an unimaginable nightmare. Across America, millions of people have joined their voices…
âYOU WONâT BELIEVE WHAT HE SAID LASTâŚâ The final words of the gunm@n behind one of the most horrifying family massacres are being revisited â and investigators say the scene inside the home was frozen in time đ đ A half-eaten meal and 6 untouched chairs were reportedly still sitting around the table when officers walked in
HORROR CRIMEÂ Chilling final words of crazed gunman who shot dead six members of same family in brutal rampage A GUNMAN screamed chilling words about death and money moments before slaughtering six of his own relatives in a horrific rampage,…
âHE WAS JUST 200 FEET FROM HOME.â đł What started as a late-night meetup in Massapequa turned into every parent’s nightmare within minutes đ đ When police arrived, a glowing phone and a single unanswered call were reportedly still visible beside the curb
DATE NIGHT HORRORÂ Son, 28, dies in dadâs arms after being âstabbed to death in his own bed by his late-night hook-up, 22â A MAN bled to death in his fatherâs arms in the middle of the night after he…
âTHEY CAME UP THROUGH THE MANHOLES.â đłđłď¸ At least 3 bizarre sewer incidents have now been reported across New York since May 5 â with mysterious men reportedly emerging from underground tunnels in Brooklyn and Queens đ But itâs what officials say is hiding beneath the cityâs âextremely dangerousâ sewer system that has people seriously unsettled⌠đ
After mystery men emerge from NYC manholes, officials warn of âextremely dangerousâ sewers Since May 5, at least three of the unexplained sewer incidents have been recorded in Brooklyn and Queens. Mystery men who are âup to no goodâ have…
End of content
No more pages to load
