A cutout of Mickey Haller is in front of The Lincoln Lawyer cast.

Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 and the Michael Connelly books!

Netflix’s The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 introduced an excellent twist for Mickey, but the season 4 casting announcements ruin the potential. Based on the eponymous book series by Michael Connelly, the legal drama follows Mickey Haller as he navigates life and cases as Los Angeles’ best defense attorney. The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 sets up Mickey for his biggest battle yet in season 4, defending himself against false murder charges for his former client Sam Scales.

Since the release of The Lincoln Lawyer season 3, fans have waited for news about whether Netflix would renew the show. Luckily, news finally broke that the fourth season would happen. Alongside the renewal, Netflix shared that Neve Campbell’s Maggie would come back full-time, and Yaya DaCosta’s Andy would leave The Lincoln Lawyer, throwing a wrench in the romance between Mickey and Andy.

Andy Leaving The Lincoln Lawyer Means Her Great Romance With Mickey Is Already Over

Andy & Mickey Were A Great Couple Who Ended Too Soon

Mickey and Andy stand together outside the courthouse in The Lincoln Lawyer. Andy and Mickey smile at each other in the kitchen in The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 episode 3 Micky and Andy in the Lincoln Lawyer season 2 courtroom

Although Mickey and Maggie are inextricably linked, Mickey and Andy were a nice change of pace. They had excellent chemistry and challenged each other throughout The Lincoln Lawyer season 3. The duo had witty back-and-forth that was entertaining to watch. Rather than criticizing Mickey for his job, Andy understood his work as a defense attorney, which is a relief after Maggie’s constant judgments. Andy and Mickey called off their relationship at the end of The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 because they wanted to focus on work. Unfortunately, Yaya DaCosta leaving the legal drama means they won’t get back together.

Andy’s Exit Sets Up Mickey & Maggie To Get Back Together In The Lincoln Lawyer Season 4

Mickey & Maggie Get Together In Michael Connelly’s The Law Of Innocence

Maggie puts her arms around Mickey's neck by the ocean in The Lincoln Lawyer season 3 episode 1

Because Mickey was in a relationship with Kendall Roberts in The Gods of Guilt, it was easy for the showrunners to switch her out for Andy without fundamentally changing the source material. However, Kendall and Mickey aren’t together in The Law of Innocence’s story – which The Lincoln Lawyer season 4 will adapt. As such, their relationship continuing would fundamentally change the book. Considering Andy’s leaving the show, it seems inevitable that Maggie and Mickey will rekindle their relationship. When speaking with Screen Rant, Ted Humphrey confirmed a harsh reality about Mickey and Andy – Maggie would always be his northern star.

Neve Campbell is returning for all ten episodes of The Lincoln Lawyer season 4, and Andy won’t be a barrier to their relationship. This is furthered by the fact that they’re following the books closely when it comes to the story and characters. In the book, she takes a leave of absence to help Mickey during the trial; then they go into COVID-19 lockdown together as a couple. Although they’ll probably scratch the pandemic storyline, The Lincoln Lawyer season 4 will undoubtedly explore the romantic pairing again.