The TV adaption of Holly Jackson’s hit novel A Good Girls Guide to Murder hit our screens this summer and we are hooked. The BBC Drama follows Pip, who investigates a murder in her town that took place five years ago, for her EPQ project. The book was beloved by readers and the TV adaptation has really lived up to the hype. With big names such as Emma Myers, Matthew Bayton and Anna Maxwell Martin joining the cast, the show soon become a classic British who-dunnit.
However, there are some noticeable differences from the book in A Good Girls Guide to Murder, so here’s a look at them all.
The hint of Andie Bell’s death at the beginning of episode one
The TV series opens with a haunting scene of Andie bell walking down a dark road, crying with blood on the back of her head, which foreshadows the unravelling of her murder. In the book, the reader is always kept in the dark about how Andie could have been murdered and where her body had disappeared, until the very end when it is all unravelled. While I do believe the first scene of the show sets the creepy tone of the series and encourages watches to be intrigued and invested in Andie, I do think it takes away from the shock of the reveal at the end.
Howie Bowers only has a small role in the show
In the series, Howie Bowers is only seen once. In the book, pip becomes obsessed with Howie and follows him to multiple drug deals and even goes to his house. However, I think the scene when we meet Howie in the show, at the calamity party, portrays him more of a mysterious and dangerous man which adds to the creepy vibe of the story.
Nat De Silva is Andie’s bestie
In the TV series it is learnt that Andie Bell was the leader of a best friend trio and Nat De Silva was one of its members. However, in the book, Nat De Silva despises Andie and they are enemies. This is due to Andie bullying Nat relentlessly as she was jealous of her and later leaking her nudes to the whole school.
Andie and Sal’s relationship is much more serious in the TV series
In the tTVv show, Andie and Sal’s relationship, although strained, is displayed as a beautiful love story with a tragic ending. They are shown to really love each other. In the book however, Andie just uses Sal as a pawn ion her game of popularity and power at school. This is why she has no remorse about cheating on him with “secret older guy”.
Sal’s alibi is hinted at in the first episode
In the book, the moment it is revealed that Sal actually does have an alibi is a big twist to readers, as it is concrete proof he is innocent. However, in the first episode of the series, Naomi Ward lets slip that Sal did have an alibi, before the conversation gets interrupted by Elliot Ward. This takes away from the drama of the moment Pip finds the photo that proves Sal was with his friends all evening, proving he couldn’t be the murderer.
Pip’s first meeting with Max is different
In the book, Pip’s first interview with Max is very brief and doesn’t contain much detail, as it is written in the form of her EPQ log. However, in the series, Pip first meets Max at his parents lavish 1920s Hollywood party, where he forces her to drink for every answer he provides to her questioning. I think this change was fantastic as it really displayed Max’s “rich boy with a dark side” persona from episode one. I also liked the theme of the party as it was reminiscent to Agatha Christie type, classic murder mysteries.
Pip learns of the nature of Sal’s and Andie deaths differently
In the book, Pip finds a scratched-out phone number in Andie’s diary and then discovers Naomi’s burner phone, who previously belonged to Elliot ward, matches the digits and figures out that Elliot must be secret older guy. In the show, Pippa finds the phone number of secret older guy in the hotel guestbook. Naomi then rings pip from her dads old phone and it matches so pip goes to confront Elliot immediately
In the book, Pip can’t stop thinking about Elliot’s genuine shock that barney had been murdered, so revisits her research and figures out herself that Max had assaulted Becca using drugs Andie had sold him, giving Becca a motive. In the show, pip sees an Instagram post which shows Elliot was out of town when barney was murdered and then finds out about Becca’s assault from her old friend.
Although these changes were made to save time and to be more visual so watchers could keep up with important details, it does give the impression that Pip is not as smart as in the book as a lot of evidence falls into her lap. Out of all the differences from the book in A Good Girls Guide to Murder, this is one which left many readers most frustrated.
There is a new side plot about Pip’s father
One of the biggest differences from the book in A Good Girls Guide to Murder is in the series, there is a plot line where Pip finds out that Victor lied about going on holiday to visit family and actually was staying down the road in a hotel. Pip believes he was cheating but you find out that it was due to marital problems. I believe this was added to show so that Pip reached a point where she felt like she couldn’t trust anyone, and neither should the audience.
Andie Bell’s personality is completely different
I believe this to be the biggest difference between the series and the book. In the tv series, it is learned that Andie had made many mistakes but it was all due to her being scared of her abusive father and a way to earn enough money to move out. Additionally, she is shown to really love Sal and want to run away with him.
However, in the books, Andie is discovered to be a manipulative bully who did things like dealing drugs to gain power over the town. Additionally, it is shown that she never really loved Sal, but he was another pawn in her game. This change is very drastic as the book takes an interesting standpoint on how victims that fit into the ‘young, beautiful, blonde’ stereotype are put on this saint-like pedestal, when actually she caused a lot of pain to others, which caused the chain events that caused her murder.
The ‘girl in the attack’ plot line is scarier
In the book, Elliot ward is struggling with guilt-driven madness and he truly believes the homeless woman he picks up on the side of the road is Andie. She plays along with it as she has had such mental distress in her life. In the series though, he does think the homeless girl is Andie initially, but then realises she isn’t but offers her somewhere to sleep for the night. This is when he tells her how he killed Sal and then refuses to let her leave as she could tell the police.
News
Adele Announces Indefinite Break From Music: “I Will Not See You For An Incredibly Long Time”
Adele has revealed she is ready to step out of the spotlight and take a well-deserved break. After an impressive run of live performances, the beloved British songstress is preparing to hit pause on her music career for a while. During…
Johnny Depp’s New Pearly Whites Shine In Video After His “Rotting” Teeth Went Viral
Johnny Depp seemed like he was living his best life while vacationing in the Bahamas, smiling and laughing away with customers and staffers at a beachside bar in Exuma. But it wasn’t just his laid-back island vibes that caught people’s attention: it was…
Queen Camilla Shares Rare Update On King Charles’ Health Amid Abdication Speculations
Amid rampant speculation about King Charles III’s health and possible abdication, Queen Camilla offered a rare comment on her husband’s well-being. The 77-year-old queen shared the update during her visit to the new state-of-the-art Dyson Cancer Center at the Royal United Hospital in…
Katy Perry Reveals Orlando Bloom Split Up With Her Because He Didn’t Want To Play Her “Games”
“I would be dead without it,” Katy Perry said about a monumental shift in her life after she broke up with her current fiancé, Orlando Bloom. The separation, which took place in 2017, happened due to an incompatibility between the lifestyles of both…
Dave Bautista’s Weight-Loss Transformation Has Fans Concerned: “He Most Definitely Looks Sick”
Dave Bautista recently addressed his striking body transformation, which left some fans raising eyebrows over his leaner appearance. The 55-year-old former WWE superstar has come a long way since his days in the wrestling ring, where his massive frame made him a force to…
“Fine Taylor … You Win”: Elon Musk Offers To Impregnate Taylor Swift
Elon Musk, who always seems eager to expand his ever-growing family, proposed the idea of fatherhood to none other than Taylor Swift. The billionaire Tesla CEO offered to impregnate the pop star after she shared her thoughts on the U.S. presidential debate, which…
End of content
No more pages to load