Before part 2 of American Horror Story: Delicate premieres in April 2024, fans have some burning questions about what will happen to Anna next.

Siobhan (Kim Kardashian) and Anna (Emma Roberts) in American Horror Story season 12

While every season of American Horror Story has big questions, intriguing mysteries, and compelling reveals, fans are particularly curious about American Horror Story season 12. With AHS: Delicate part 2 premiering soon, it’s the perfect time to try to put all the puzzle pieces of the last few episodes together and guess what is going to happen next. These nine episodes follow determined actress Anna Victoria Alcott (Emma Roberts) who doesn’t know who to trust when she finally gets pregnant after a long time of trying. Of course, since this is Ryan Murphy’s anthology series, she has scary visions, gets up close to raccoons, and is terrified for herself and her unborn baby.

American Horror Story season 12 has been compared to Rosemary’s Baby, which has its own terrifying ending. AHS fans have some burning questions that they hope will be answered by the time all of the episodes of the season drop.

What Does The Cult Choose Anna In American Horror Story Season 12?

Ashley (Billie Lourd), Siobhan (Kim Kardashian), Ashleigh (Leslie Grossman), and Anna (Emma Roberts) in American Horror Story: Delicate

From the beginning of American Horror Story season 12, it’s clear that there is a cult who want Anna to get pregnant so they can possibly take her baby once he or she is born. One of the biggest questions fans discussed in a Reddit thread is why the cult picks Anna and not someone else. Redditor @ranchcommerical asked,

“What makes Anna so special that they keep trying with her specifically?”

The end of American Horror Story season 12 part 1 brought up many questions about the cult and wondering if Anna’s publicist Siobhan Corbyn (Kim Kardashian) is involved. Hopefully by the end of American Horror Story: Delicate part 2, the cult’s intentions will be explained.

Fans continue to wonder about Anna being the host for the cult’s baby in this season of the anthology series that feels like an eerie horror movie about pregnancy. Redditor @iamronbuurgundy added, “they knock her out during IVF to do some kind of rituals” and Redditor @LyonPirkey wrote, “I was thinking that the ‘cult’ was trying to transfer their ‘cult’ baby. Anna, for the ‘cult’ is someone to simply carry the baby. I’m not sure why they picked Anna.”

American Horror Story season 12 fans also think that Anna’s husband Dex and his late Eve could have been part of the cult, which would explain the decision to get Anna pregnant. Redditor @Jnm124 wrote:

“Wondering if Eve and/or Dex were a part of the cult and they’re trying to rebirth her thru anna? i wish we knew more about Dex’s background but that obviously takes away the mystery.”

Redditor @nobleheartedkate added that the cult could have impregnated Anna with Eve’s eggs, which would definitely be creepy.

Does Anna Miss Time In American Horror Story Season 12?

Anna (Emma Roberts) in American Horror Story: Delicate

Another big question about American Horror Story season 12 is whether Anna misses time. This seems to represent the state of Anna’s mind and how traumatized she has been by the stress of her career and trying to conceive. While these scenes do prove that AHS is one of the best anthology TV series because the storylines are well-crafted, they can be confusing.

Billie Lourd, KIm Kardashian and Leslie Grossman in American Horror Story Delicate
Emma Roberts in American Horror Story Delicate Emma Roberts and Kim Kardashian in American Horror Story Delicate Emma Roberts in American Horror Story Delicate Michaela Jaé Rodriguez in American Horror Story Delicate

In a Reddit thread, Redditor @be1izabeth0908 asked about a potential continuity error in American Horror Story season 12 episode 2, “Rockabye.” They mentioned that Anna is making soup that changes color depending on the date on the calendar that Anna is using to count down until when she can take a pregnancy test. The fan wrote, “My theory so far is that Anna is hallucinating and/or being drugged and gaslit” but “Do we think Anna is actually missing time or going into a fugue state? Or is this a dumb continuity error I’m reading too far into?” Several fans commented that Anna has lost periods of time because of her mental state and the terror that is happening to her.

What Will Happen To Anna’s Baby In American Horror Story Season 12?

Anna (Emma Roberts) and Dex (Matt Czuchry) in American Horror Story: Delicate

American Horror Story season 12 fans are also curious about whether the cult will take Anna’s baby after she gives birth. Ever since the finale of American Horror Story season 1, viewers have expected engaging, creepy, and unforgettable season finales that answer all the necessary questions. It seems likely that one of the next four episodes will feature a terrifying scene of Anna giving birth. It will no doubt rival some of the most memorable elements of the franchise, from learning that Tate Langdon (Evan Peters) is a ghost to seeing the Rubber Man, Twisty the Clown, and other horrifying AHS villains.

When fans discussed theories for American Horror Story season 12 part 1 on Reddit, Redditor @Certain_Horse_7919 wrote:

“I too want to know why they need these demon babies. My guess is anchor points for the devil to be on earth.”

In another Reddit thread, Redditor @bvanvolk asked what Anna’s baby could be and how they fit into the horror franchise. They wrote:

“The biggest mystery right now is what these demon babies are supposed to be. Why do we need more than one? What purpose do they fulfill within the AHS universe, compared to everything else we already know about the universe (ex: the two antichrists, witches, ghosts, hellmouths, etc.).”