When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: New Line Cinema and Warner Bros.)

When I was a little kid, I thought Gandalf and Dumbledore were the same person, meaning I didn’t just think the same actor played them, I thought they were the same wizard. Well, I quickly figured out that I was wrong, and I also swiftly fell in love with Ian McKellen’s Lord of the Rings istar and Michael Gambon’s take on Hogwarts’ Headmaster. However, it turns out I wasn’t the only one who confused the fantasy characters, because McKellen hilariously explained how he and Gambon dealt with the frequent mix-ups from fans.

Let me set the scene for these hilarious comments from McKellen. He was doing an interview with Magic Radio, and he mentioned that on his way to this radio spot, he saw himself on a bus. He said he didn’t think he’d ever seen himself on the side of a bus before, but the interviewer couldn’t quite believe that – especially considering his prominent roles in the casts of Lord of the Rings and X-Men. This led the actor to explain that when the Harry Potter movies came out, people thought he was on the side of busses, but it was really the late great Michael Gambon:

There was a time when they were making the Harry Potter movies and with each movie, they made Dumbledore, Mike Gambon, look more and more like Gandalf. By the last movie, it was Gandalf up there on the busses. And I said, ‘Well, I might have been in a film I didn’t know I’d made.’

In Sir Ian McKellen and I’s defense, on the surface it’s easy to mistake Gandalf and Dumbledore. They’re both wizards in fantasy projects that are regarded as some of the best movies of the 2000s, they both wear robes of the grey and white variety, they both have long gray hair, and they’re both extremely wise and regal.

They also serve similar purposes in their respective franchises. In the Harry Potter movies, Dumbledore is Harry and the students’ advisor and guardian. In the Lord of the Rings films, Gandalf helps Frodo, the Fellowship and the beings of Middle-earth in the same kind of way, by being a wise protector.

However, while the switch-up is understandable (and the 8-year-old version of myself is 100% guilty of it), both Gambon and McKellen deserve (and have received) acclaim and praise for their respective and different performances.

Luckily, though, when these mistakes happen, they both are funny about it, as McKellen described how Gambon would act when someone asked him to sign an image of Gandalf:

I once asked Gambon did he ever get mistaken for me? He said ‘Oh, the whole time.’ I said ‘What did you do?’ He said, ‘Oh, they bring me their wretched photos of Gandalf, and I just sign your name.’

So, if you have a signed photo of Gandalf you might want to reassess who you met that day, because it might have been Michael Gambon. However, either way, that meet-up is a win.