‘Star Wars: The Acolyte’ is the latest addition to the Star Wars franchise. The show, which ran for 8 episodes, was recently canceled due to its high cost, overwhelmingly negative feedback, and lack of viewership.

One of the main criticisms was its unexpected portrayal of the Jedi in a negative light and its subversion of typical protagonist expectations. Fans who followed the show closely would know that the protagonist, Osha, ultimately succumbs to the dark side. After killing her father figure and her former Jedi Master, she aligns herself with Qimir, the newly introduced Sith Lord.

The dynamic between Osha and Jedi Master Sol is partially inspired by Headland’s personal experiences. In an interview with Vulture, the showrunner revealed that she initially intended to focus on the relationship between two sisters. However, following some tragic events in her life, she shifted her focus to explore the “daughter” and “father” relationship, drawing parallels to the dynamic between Luke and Darth Vader.

The image of Luke slaying Vader in the Dagobah cave and then seeing his own face in the helmet really stuck with me from childhood. It was a talisman I would always touch, like, This is what it’s about. What if I’m the bad guy? Do I feel like the bad guy, but I’m not? Am I being villainized by the people I love most? Or is this thing already in me and the otherness, the thing I’m afraid of, what I should embrace about myself?

I started out wanting to explore the sister relationship , then my father got very sick in the middle of developing this and it turned into this father-daughter relationship. My dad died in September. As we moved forward with the story, I got sucked into my own feelings about his illness and our history together. Kathleen said, “George wrote about his father. You need to write about your sister. You need to write about your father.” Luke felt betrayed by his father in the way that George didn’t want to take over his father’s hardware store. My father made so many promises to me, and I felt like I failed because I couldn’t live up to those expectations. Of course I’m going to lean toward the other side, the dark side, the otherness. That system has its own societal expectations, but I’m more comfortable there than when I was trying to live up to what you wanted for me.

When you have the type of father Sol is, there’s an inability to recognize that paternalism as insular. Osha has to destroy her father to keep moving. I don’t know what it means, but for father-son relationships in Star Wars, there’s reconciliation. For father-daughter, there isn’t.

The relationship between the two sisters in the show was also influenced by Headland’s personal experiences, as she has revealed being estranged from her youngest sister.

Headland also explained that Osha’s decision to kill Sol was driven by a desire to overcome “benign sexism” and to assert her own agency, breaking free from the expectations imposed on her by her father figure.

What are your thoughts on this? Share them in the comments below!