Another familiar franchise actor already attached to the project is Ian McKellen, who played Gandalf in each of The Lord of the Rings and Hobbit movies. McKellen shared that he had been approached to play the beloved wizard again and later mentioned that he was told The Hunt for Gollum will be two movies. This development has not yet been officially confirmed, but if it proves to be true, it will follow in the footsteps of a previous misstep for the fantasy franchise.
It Sounds Like The Hunt For Gollum Could Repeat A Lord Of The Rings Franchise Mistake
The Hobbit Shouldn’t Have Been A Trilogy
If The Hunt for Gollum is split into two movies, I fear that it will make the same mistake as The Hobbit movies, which took the approximately 300-page source material and needlessly overextended it into a trilogy. Each of the trilogy’s installments was a financial success, and I enjoyed various aspects of each movie, but they were ultimately not an effective adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s source material. This was especially glaring in The Battle of the Five Armies, which mostly focused on a battle that is only a brief part of the book.
Movie
Popcornmeter Score
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)
64%
83%
The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013)
74%
85%
The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014)
59%
74%
The Hobbit is supposed to be the story of Bilbo Baggins, but Bilbo misses much of the battle due to being temporarily knocked unconscious. Martin Freeman did a fantastic job portraying Bilbo, but the movie trilogy lost sight of his arc as it progressed and focused more on massive battle sequences and on characters and storylines that were not in the book, including Thorin’s conflict with Azog the Defiler and the inclusion of Legolas. The Hobbit only needed to be two movies at most, while The Hunt for Gollum only needs to be one movie.
Splitting The Hunt For Gollum Into Two Movies Doesn’t Make Sense
It Lacks The Source Material Needed To Be Two Movies
While The Hobbit trilogy had a full novel to adapt, The Hunt for Gollum has far less to draw from, as there is no existing source material fully dedicated to this story. There are only references throughout Tolkien’s works, including Aragorn telling the Council of Rivendell in The Fellowship of the Ring that there was “little need to tell of” what happened while hunting for Gollum. The Battle of the Five Armies did not need to be its own movie, but at least there was enough information in The Hobbit to expand upon the titular conflict.
Even the franchise’s upcoming standalone anime movie, War of the Rohirrim , seems like it has a bigger story to tell than The Hunt for Gollum does, which makes the latter’s two-movie potential even more questionable.
The Hunt for Gollum is based on limited information from Tolkien’s writings, which may make its connections to The Lord of the Rings feel too tenuous. This makes me concerned that there may not be enough to warrant one movie, and splitting the story into two movies only makes the issue worse. Even the franchise’s upcoming standalone anime movie, War of the Rohirrim, seems like it has a bigger story to tell than The Hunt for Gollum does, which makes the latter’s two-movie potential even more questionable.
I Really Hope Ian McKellen’s Lord Of The Rings Movie Update Isn’t True
The Hunt For Gollum Shouldn’t Be Two Movies
Since The Hunt for Gollum still seems to be in relatively early stages, I am hoping that it will not actually end up being two movies. I was already concerned that the movie was being made not because it had a compelling story to tell, but because of Warner Bros. Discovery CEO David Zaslav wanting to further capitalize on the popular intellectual properties owned by his company. Taking a dubious premise and potentially already committing to it being two movies does nothing to alleviate those concerns.
The Lord of the Rings is one of the most commercially and critically successful trilogies of all time, but this does not mean that every live-action Middle-earth project needs to be turned into multiple movies. One does not need to be intimately familiar with Lord of the Rings‘ lore to know that there is only so much that can happen with Gollum and the One Ring prior to Fellowship, another sign that multiple installments are not needed. All of these factors leave me hoping The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum will only be one movie instead of two.
News
Sauron’s True Power in ‘Rings of Power’ Season 2 Has Nothing To Do With Actual Rings
It would appear that Season 2 of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is a marked improvement on Season 1, providing deeper cuts into J. R. R. Tolkien‘s lore, and a better balance between the fantastical elements and horror elements. However,…
The Rings of Power fans are convinced Adar is going to meet a terrible fate: “Dude’s about to die the most gruesome death to ever grace a screen”
(Image credit: Amazon Studios) The Rings of Power season 2 has everyone speculating about what might happen to Adar. The character, played by Sam Hazeldine, is an all-original creation of the Prime Video show and does not exist in J.R.R. Tolkien’s works,…
Hugh Grant’s Dungeons & Dragons Comments Highlight The Harsh Reality For Honor Among Thieves 2
Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves was a great introduction to the legendary game for many, but it disappointed at the box office and Hugh Grant may understand why. Although not the first movie in the Dungeons & Dragons franchise, Dungeons & Dragons: Honor…
One House Of The Dragon Season 2 Scene Didn’t Make The Final Cut And Fans Are Relieved
House of the Dragon season 2 was divisive enough already, and I’m glad one insane scene didn’t make it into the show. With some time away from season 2 to collect my thoughts, I still have mixed feelings about its treatment of…
Galadriel’s Replacement Is The Character The Rings Of Power Always Needed
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power presented Galadriel as the main character of season 1, for better or worse, but Rings of Power season 2 offers a different focus, which is paying dividends for the show. Morfydd Clark was exceptional as…
Why 1 Rings Of Power Human Character Shouldn’t Be Given A Ring Explained By LOTR Star: “That Will Be A Disaster”
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power star Leon Wadham explains why one character in the show should never be given a ring. Taking place during the Second Age of Middle-earth, Prime Video’s epic fantasy series adapts the works…
End of content
No more pages to load