Carrie Underwood ditched her signature sparkles and fringe in favor of waders and a hoodie for an outdoor adventure that left some fans doing a double take.

On Saturday, September 14, the 41-year-old actress took to Instagram to share a carousel of photos from her fly-fishing trip in Montana. Throughout a series of 12 photos, Carrie can be seen with her husband, Mike Fisher, and posing solo with what are presumed to be her catches of the day.

While it’s unrealistic to think that the “All-American Girl” singer lives each and every day of her life dressed to the nines with a full face of makeup and rhinestones galore, many fans were shocked by her more casual appearance.

This content is imported from instagram. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

“I think she is great but, all honesty, I can’t recognize her. She is and always has been so naturally beautiful,” one fan questioned. “She does look different. Still absolutely beautiful! Did she get her teeth done? Not putting her down just wondering,” another fan questioned.

Meanwhile, some found Carrie’s new look to be a breath of fresh air. “Pictures like these show how beautifully down-to-earth you are! A real country girl,” one fan exclaimed. “That’s the Carrie Underwood I like to see,” someone else wrote. “Can this grown woman post without someone commenting on her looks? Y’all need to worry about yourself and not Carrie Underwood’s teeth. Good lord,” another fan chimed in.

While it’s really nobody’s business how Carrie decides to dress or accentuate her face, some fans were quick to remind others of the singer’s gruesome fall in November 2017. While walking her dogs, Carrie missed a step and fell face first, breaking her wrist and requiring 40+ stitches to fix the damage inside and outside of her mouth. Following the incident, the country star admitted that her confidence took a hit.

So, perhaps before immediately judging, fans could benefit from leaning into compassion before the comments section.