Hailey Baldwin seems to have a very good relationship with her mother-in-law Pattie Mallette.

Justin Bieber’s biological mother   – Pattie Mallette – and daughter-in-law Hailey Baldwin were recently spotted enjoying cold yogurt together at a store in Laguna Beach, California. According to paparazzi, the two seemed extremely comfortable and close during the outing. 

In particular, Justin Bieber does not appear at all in the recorded photos. It can be seen that Bieber’s mother-in-law and daughter-in-law had a private date without the male singer’s presence. This is also something that Ms. Pattie Mallette freely openly did with her new daughter-in-law Hailey Baldwin instead of with her son Selena Gomez’s ex-lover.

Hailey Baldwin revealed her diamond engagement ring during an outing with her mother-in-law, wearing a long silver silk dress combined with white sneakers and a jacket from her husband’s fashion brand. Even though she is 43 years old, Ms. Pattie Mallette is still extremely youthful and stylish with her unique, eye-catching black outfit.

Previously, Justin’s mother loved Selena Gomez very much and tried to reunite her son with Selena. Ms. Pattie was also very surprised when Justin quickly proposed to Hailey Baldwin last July, but she respected her son’s decision. 

Not only that, Ms. Pattie also publicly expressed her affection for her daughter-in-law many times by praising her on social networks. The good mother-in-law and daughter-in-law relationship between Ms. Pattie and Hailey makes many Justin Bieber fans happy.