Do balrogs have wings? And can they fly?
At this point, you might wonder if I’m joking. Of course balrogs can fly; they have wings. They’ve always had wings. The one in the Peter Jackson movies has wings. But what if I told you that when Peter Jackson and crew chose to depict the balrog with wings, they were making a somewhat controversial choice?
What if I told you that the question of whether balrogs have wings at all has been vexing Tolkien scholars for decades?
Image: Amazon Studios
The source of the problem is that all of the language that Tolkien used to refer to the “wings” of balrogs and their “flight” is open to interpretation.
The first description of a balrog’s form comes in the Moria sequence of The Fellowship of the Ring. And the first reference to it having “wings” comes after several paragraphs that simply describe it as an enormous, maned, man-shaped figure, wielding a sword in one hand and a whip in the other, obscured in fire, shadow, and smoke. And in this first mention, Tolkien explicitly doesn’t say that the balrog has wings. He says the darkness around it looks like wings: “the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings,” as the balrog squares up with Gandalf on the bridge of Khazad-dûm.
The next reference, two paragraphs later, describes the balrog’s fire dying down, and the shadow around it increasing, until “suddenly it drew itself up to a great height, and its wings were spread from wall to wall.” In isolation, this language is more literal. But taken with the first reference, it can be argued that Tolkien is simply elegantly referring to the previous simile, without intending a literal meaning — which is a generally observable pattern in the descriptive writing through his novelistic work.
A few paragraphs later, the bridge crumbles under Gandalf’s staff, and the balrog falls into the abyss. Tolkien writes: “its shadow plunged down and vanished.” Which raises other good arguments for flightless balrogs: If the balrog could fly, why couldn’t it fly up out of the chasm? Why would Gandalf have even tried smashing the bridge under its feet in the first place, if he knew it was capable of flight?
And not to get too deep into textual analysis, but suffice to say, for every time Tolkien referred to balrogs in The Silmarillion as “flying with winged speed” or “passing over” a great distance, there is a counter-example of him using “flight” simply to mean “escape” or referring to whole land-bound armies as “passing over” a country. And there are many references, in Tolkien’s early writings that include balrogs, to balrogs being part of ground-bound armies, of the powers of evil containing no flying monsters to match the Great Eagles, etc.
But on the other hand, The Silmarillion was published posthumously, as compiled from Tolkien’s most complete writings, not necessarily his most up to date. And we could keep going around in circles in this way for hours.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, a show that seems to want to align itself visually with the Peter Jackson movies, has a balrog that looks a dead ringer for the one in Jackson’s Moria, complete with curved horns, a skull-like face, and great winged appendages covered in cascading smoke. But can it fly? The show has not yet clearly put a foot down in that arena: We don’t see it fly in its brief appearance, but we do see it fall, flapping its wings in either an unsuccessful attempt to rise into the air or in a successful attempt to control its descent. So it too is open to interpretation, at least for now.
People will debate whether balrogs have wings and can fly until humanity is a fairy tale in books written by rabbits, because there are compelling textual arguments for both sides and the “real” answer will never be known. It’s the “Is a hot dog a sandwich?” of Tolkien studies/fandom, the “Do you say it gif or jif?” It’s a question that’s fun to consider, so long as you take it with the weight of a Buddhist koan, and not the greatest thread in the history of forums, locked by a moderator after 12,239 pages of heated debate.
The most open truth is that Tolkien wrote a lot of descriptions of balrogs that could be interpreted as giving them wings and the ability to fly, but he also never explicitly stated that they have wings and can fly, not in any material that he himself saw all the way to publication. Both sides are potentially right and potentially wrong in equal measure.
You can even hold both ideas simultaneously, like this: “Yeah, the textual support is limited in certain ways, but, in all earnestness, the wings look cool as hell, and it’s all made-up fantastical mythopoeic opera anyway, so why not? The balrog in The Fellowship of the Ring isn’t described as having horns, either, and they look great. Maybe the chasm under the bridge of Khazad-dûm was too narrow for the balrog’s wings to work?”
Anyway, that’s my take on it. Now to take a nice leisurely sip of this delicious water, and look at the comments section…
News
Joe Locke Discusses Tommy’s Possible Return in ‘Agatha All Along’
This week’s episode of Agatha All Along finally shed light on Billy’s motives and why he sought out Agatha in the first place. It turns out Billy had some awareness of his true origins all along and was cleverly manipulating Agatha, though she would…
Hugh Jackman’s Brown & Tan $100K Wolverine Suit Looks Cheap Compared to the Shocking Price of Shazam’s Costume!
Producing superhero movies involves significant expenses, largely due to CGI, action sequences, and, surprisingly, the costumes. Striking a balance between functionality, comic accuracy, and realism, superhero suits have evolved considerably from their early designs. We recently talked about this, and…
Joe Locke Would Like to Team Up with Ms. Marvel in a Potential ‘Young Avengers’ Project
After the most recent revelations in Agatha All Along, Joe Locke, now confirmed to be Wiccan (as we correctly predicted), is once again in the spotlight. Of course, we are duty-bound to report on the latest news related to both the character and the…
Jenna Ortega Could Join the Marvel Cinematic Universe
Hollywood’s rising star Jenna Ortega, known for her roles in the Scream revival, Netflix’s Wednesday, and the recent Beetlejuice sequel, is now catching the eye of Marvel Studios. Reports from MTTSH indicate that she’s currently in discussions for a role within the Marvel Cinematic Universe, although…
Exciting Twist in Fan Theory: ‘Agatha All Along’ Showrunner Confirms Deleted Scene with Alice Wu
Agatha All Along is the newest addition to the MCU, exploring the magical and supernatural aspects of the cinematic universe that were only lightly addressed in earlier projects. The series introduces a host of new characters and mysteries, including Alice Wu, a…
Marvel Cancels Its Only TV Show with Perfect 100% RT Score
Marvel Studios, known for its reluctance to officially cancel shows, opting instead for the ‘limited series’ tag, appears to have made a rare move. A beloved series praised for its engaging storytelling and critical acclaim, confirmed through storyboard artist Gabi…
End of content
No more pages to load