In countering the regularly touted claim that a large portion of the game’s critics are aggressive racists, a new report has found that the negative conversations surrounding Assassin’s Creed Shadows are actually “less toxic” than the average video game discourse.
The report in question was compiled by video game-centric analytics firm PlayerXP through the use of their titular AI, which “harnesses the power of Machine Learning to monitor and analyse player feedback from across the web” to “provide accurate sentiment analysis for studios and publishers to make informed decisions based on player feedback”, the results of which are laid out on a scale of -99 (Very Negative) to 99 (Very Positive) .
Using the AI to analyze a total of 129,633 interactions which took place across YouTube, X (Twitter), Facebook, and TikTok, and between May 15th – the day of the game’s official reveal – and July 23rd, the firm found that overall players were overall unimpressed with what Ubisoft had to offer.
“YouTube, X, and Facebook showed largely negative sentiments,” explained PlayerXP. “TikTok, in contrast, reflects an overall positive sentiment.”
Proceeding to expand on their findings, the firm noted that “the most popular talking points relate to the historical setting of the game, Ubisoft, the publisher and Japanese culture depicted in the game.”
“These all have significant negative sentiment associated, with the historical element being the most negative,” they detailed. “This has been driven by players expressing concerns about the historical accuracy and cultural depiction.
The data set looked at for PlayerXP’s Community Sentiment Report for Assassin’s Creed Shadows
PlayerXP also offered a specific analysis of the conversations regarding Assassin’s Creed Shadows highly fictionalized take on the historical Yasuke.
“The debate around Yasuke’s character, and similar discussions, underscore the broader concerns about the game’s historical accuracy,” said the firm. “Given that Assassin’s Creed Shadows is based on historical fiction, deviations from historical facts are to be expected. However, this also means we shouldn’t anticipate universally positive reactions from the community on these topics.”
To this end, the firm ultimately concluded, “The issue of the character’s ethnicity in Assassin’s Creed Shadows has been heavily debated, however our toxicity tool has shown the community less toxic than the industry average, with a [sentiment scale] score of -37.”Yasuke (TBA) and Naoe (TBA) prepare to assault the local Daimyo’s stronghold in Assassin’s Creed Shadows (2024), Ubisoft
Furthermore, the firm found that rather than Yasuke or the game’s bastardization of history, the element of Assassin’s Creed Shadows that actually drew the most player outrage was “Ubisoft’s perceived prioritization of monetization strategies over player experience.”
“The consistent negative feedback regarding monetization strategies suggests that players feel unheard, affecting their overall trust in Ubisoft,” they added.
Yasuke (TBA) reveals himself in Assassin’s Creed Shadows (2024), Ubisoft
While these findings are sure to be welcome by anyone who has been accused of being a bigot for criticizing Ubisoft’s creative choices, in the interest of fairness, it should be noted that the findings are not complete in any sense.
Between the AI’s analysis being limited to just written comments (rather than spoken criticisms), its sample size being relatively small (for comparison, while the report looked at 129,633 overall interactions, the official upload of game’s debut trailer alone has 91,824 comments), and the exact process and methodology by which the AI made its findings currently being withheld from the public, it’s clear that PlayerXP’s report does not paint a full-picture of the overall discourse surrounding Assassin’s Creed Shadows‘.
Yasuke (TBA) steels himself to save a local village from some bandits in Assassin’s Creed Shadows (2024), Ubisoft
However, much to the chagrin of the game’s supporters, these flaws do not change the report’s general findings – that rather than being based in racism, the criticisms being leveled against Ubisoft’s next title are more the result of players being fed up with being blatantly insulted by Triple A publishers.
Assassin’s Creed Shadows is set to unsheath its katana on November 12th.
News
Unreal Engine Coding Standards Require Video Game Studios To Use “Inclusive” Language In Programming And Documentation
Dr. Slone lives once more in Fortnite (2024), Epic Games In proving that identity politics have quite literally seeped into the very DNA of video games, Epic Games has taken to encouraging developers who use their popular Unreal Engine to…
Warner Bros. Games Launches New ‘Women And Non-Binary Leadership Program’ In Order To “Upend The Gaming Industry’s Male-Dominated Characterization”
Amanda Waller (Debra Wilson) is fed-up with Captain Boomerang’s (Daniel Lapaine) back talk in Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League (2024), Rocksteady Studios In an announcement that’s sure to help the studio rehabilitate its reputation following its recent Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice…
‘Halo’ Series Composer Says Video Game Industry Now Pandering Because They Fear “Being On The Wrong Side Of Some Special Interest Groups Who Can Be Very Loud And Very Annoying”
The Arbiter (Keith David) and the Master Chief (Steve Downes) find themselves backed into a corner in Halo 3 (2007), Bungie In providing anecdotal confirmation to one of most widely assumed reasons for the currently abysmal state of Western entertainment,…
Rumor: PlayStation Studios Seeking Non-White Transgender Actor To Lead New Game, Story Will Focus On “How Their Culture Does Not Accept Women As Leaders In Their Community”
Emari (Christine Rose Schermerhorn) reports for duty in Concord (2025), Firewalk Studios According to a new whisper on the digital streets, Sony’s PlayStation Studios is currently looking to develop a new game centered on a male-to-female transgender protagonist who seeks…
Square Enix Shareholder Presses Company President On Relationship With Sweet Baby Inc., Receives Non-Answer In Return
Maxine Caulfield (Hannah Telle), Safiya Llewellyn-Fayyad (Olivia AbiAssi), and Moses Murphy (Blu Allen) take a snowy selfie in Life is Strange: Double Exposure (2024), Square Enix A recent Square Enix investor meeting reportedly saw a shareholder directly press the company…
‘God Of War Ragnarök’ Writer Alanah Pearce Argues ‘Elden Ring’ Is “Not Accessible To Disabled Players”, Claims “It Counts As A Disability If You Have A 2-Year-Old”
Messmer (Jack Barton) goads The Tarnished into continuing their fight in Elden Ring: Shadows of the Erdtree (2024), FromSoft Noted video game personality Alanah Pearce is adding her voice to the chorus of critics who believes the core fundamentals of…
End of content
No more pages to load