As Shōgun wins big at the Emmys, a Japanese historian reveals major historical inaccuracies, challenging its portrayal of samurai culture.
Rachel Kondo and Justin Marks’ historical drama series, Shōgun, was the winner of the night as it swept the Creative Arts Emmy Awards on Sunday night. Nominated in over 25 categories, the series won 14 awards in total, the most for any series for one season in history, and can win more when the main Emmys ceremony is held on September 15.
Shōgun | Credit: FX/Hulu
One of the highest-rated historical drama series of all time, the show has consistently shocked viewers and critics with its storyline, plot, direction, and more, making it a fan favorite. While many applaud it for apparently being true to ‘history’ a Japanese historian recently pointed out several inaccuracies that we had no idea about.
Shōgun Bags 14 Awards at the Creative Emmy Awards
Shōgun has won 14 Emmys so far | Credit: FX/Hulu
When the Hiroyuki Sanada-starrer Shōgun was announced, many anticipated it might be a masterpiece in the making. And it certainly has turned out to be so considering the widespread critical acclaim it has received for nearly every aspect of the show, ranging from acting, directing to visuals and faithfulness to its source material.
Based on the 1975 novel by James Clavell, has an impeccable rating across different sites from fans and critics alike (see Google). And so when it received a total of 25 nominations at the Emmy Awards, many expected the series would hit it big, which it certainly did.
On the second night of the Creative Arts Emmy Awards, just a single season of the series ended up winning a whopping 14 awards in total and might even win more at the main Emmy ceremony being held on September 15. Winning in various categories that included costumes, makeup, stunts, editing, cinematography, and more, it broke the previous record held by the 2008 limited series John Adams.
Furthermore, setting a new record, the series companion movie/documentary The Making of Shōgun went on to bag another Emmy in the Short Form Nonfiction or Reality Series category (via Entertainment Weekly). As the cast and crew as well as the fans of the series celebrate this monumental win, a Japanese historian recently pointed out several historical inaccuracies in the show, which makes us see the series in a new light.
Japanese Historian Exposes Shōgun‘s Historical Inaccuracies that Will Leave Fans Shocked
Japanese Historian points out several historical inaccuracies in Hiroyuki Sanada-starrer Shōgun | Credit: FX/Hulu
Shōgun is based on written text, a book to be exact. So when it was under production, fans of the book hoped it would remain true to its source, which it has largely turned out to be. However, this does not mean the historical drama series is true to history, as many believed it was as far as the reviews go (see THR).
Recently a Japanese historian, Toshi Kahara pointed out in a written feature in the Japanese news outlet, President (via Reddit), the many inaccurate depictions of history the series has. Kahara pointed out that while even the architecture was inaccurate, the most controversial depiction of the show was Samurais drawing out their swords too often.
Realistically, bushis rarely drew their swords unless it was absolute necessary. In the Edo period, if a samurai thoughtlessly drew his sword and cut someone, his bloodline will be cut off or be sentenced to commit seppuku.
Although the show featured Samurais before the Edo period, them drawing out their sword every so often is controversial and problematic nonetheless. Furthermore, the historian revealed Samurais didn’t commit seppuku that easily or that often. Hailing the notion that Samurais committed seppuku often is a Western construct, he also pointed out how the ship crew being abused and boiled was something that rarely ever happened.
Seppuku scene in Shōgun | Credit: FX/Hulu
Even the book it is based on had several historical inaccuracies, given how the author based most characters on real historical figures, with John Blackthorne being closely based on the accounts of the English Navigator William Adams. Labeling Harakiri and Geisha as more than just stereotypes, the historian further pointed out the series’ depicting Shōgun as a prominent title, when in reality it was Kampaku (advisor to the Emperor) which was much higher in rank and difficult to ascend to.
Also calling out the show for presenting Japan and Japanese people and customs of that time as barbaric for mere dramatic effect, Toshi Kahara did not hold back in expressing his discomfort with the show. Having pointed out several other problems with the series, his account will certainly shock fans and critics, who were now heralding it for its largely historically true nature.
With two more seasons on the way (via Deadline), only time will tell how the series will fare and whether or not it will take such criticism into account and mend its approach.
Shōgun is available to be streamed on Disney+.
News
Adele Announces Indefinite Break From Music: “I Will Not See You For An Incredibly Long Time”
Adele has revealed she is ready to step out of the spotlight and take a well-deserved break. After an impressive run of live performances, the beloved British songstress is preparing to hit pause on her music career for a while. During…
Johnny Depp’s New Pearly Whites Shine In Video After His “Rotting” Teeth Went Viral
Johnny Depp seemed like he was living his best life while vacationing in the Bahamas, smiling and laughing away with customers and staffers at a beachside bar in Exuma. But it wasn’t just his laid-back island vibes that caught people’s attention: it was…
Queen Camilla Shares Rare Update On King Charles’ Health Amid Abdication Speculations
Amid rampant speculation about King Charles III’s health and possible abdication, Queen Camilla offered a rare comment on her husband’s well-being. The 77-year-old queen shared the update during her visit to the new state-of-the-art Dyson Cancer Center at the Royal United Hospital in…
Katy Perry Reveals Orlando Bloom Split Up With Her Because He Didn’t Want To Play Her “Games”
“I would be dead without it,” Katy Perry said about a monumental shift in her life after she broke up with her current fiancé, Orlando Bloom. The separation, which took place in 2017, happened due to an incompatibility between the lifestyles of both…
Dave Bautista’s Weight-Loss Transformation Has Fans Concerned: “He Most Definitely Looks Sick”
Dave Bautista recently addressed his striking body transformation, which left some fans raising eyebrows over his leaner appearance. The 55-year-old former WWE superstar has come a long way since his days in the wrestling ring, where his massive frame made him a force to…
“Fine Taylor … You Win”: Elon Musk Offers To Impregnate Taylor Swift
Elon Musk, who always seems eager to expand his ever-growing family, proposed the idea of fatherhood to none other than Taylor Swift. The billionaire Tesla CEO offered to impregnate the pop star after she shared her thoughts on the U.S. presidential debate, which…
End of content
No more pages to load