Leaked Fan Theory: Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara’s “Accidental Touches” – A Scandalous Glimpse Behind the Scenes of the Culpables Trilogy

In the glittering yet treacherous world of Hollywood-adjacent Spanish cinema, where on-screen passion often blurs into off-screen intrigue, few stories have captivated fans quite like that of Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara. The duo, who ignited global screens as the star-crossed lovers Noah and Nick in Prime Video’s Culpables trilogy—My Fault (Culpa Mía, 2023), Your Fault (Culpa Tuya, 2024), and Our Fault (Culpa Nuestra, 2025)—have long been the subject of fervent shipping. Their electric chemistry, evident in every lingering gaze and heated embrace, has spawned endless fan edits, TikTok montages, and whispered rumors of a real-life romance. But now, a leaked fan analysis circulating on gossip pages and X (formerly Twitter) has taken the speculation to new heights: claims of six “accidental touches” during filming that suggest something far more intimate than scripted affection. With Gabriel Guevara’s confirmed girlfriend, actress María de Nati, in the picture, these moments aren’t just cute—they’re downright scandalous.

The theory, first gaining traction in late 2024 on anonymous Threads accounts and Reddit threads before exploding across X in early 2025, posits that Wallace and Guevara couldn’t keep their hands off each other, even when the cameras weren’t rolling. Titled “6 Unscripted Sparks: The Touches That Broke the Set,” the analysis dissects behind-the-scenes clips, bloopers, and leaked set photos, arguing these “accidents” reveal a forbidden attraction simmering beneath their professional facade. As one viral X post from fan account @gabicolevibes put it: “Their chemistry is criminal. If these touches were accidents, then I’m the Queen of England. 👀 #GabiCole #CulpaNuestra.” With the trilogy’s finale Our Fault dropping on October 16, 2025, and drawing over 50 million streams in its first week, the timing couldn’t be more explosive. Fans are divided: some swoon over the romance, others decry it as disrespectful to De Nati. But what’s fact, fiction, and fan-fueled fantasy? Let’s dive into the drama.

To understand the allure, one must rewind to 2023, when My Fault burst onto Prime Video like a summer storm. Adapted from Mercedes Ron’s wildly popular Wattpad saga Culpables, the film follows 17-year-old Noah (Wallace), a rebellious teen forced to live with her mother’s new fiancé and his enigmatic son, Nick (Guevara). What starts as familial tension erupts into a steamy, forbidden romance fraught with jealousy, betrayal, and high-octane drama—think Romeo and Juliet with motorcycles and more shirtless scenes. Wallace, then 21 and fresh off Spanish TV gigs like El secreto de Puente Viejo, brought a raw vulnerability to Noah, while 22-year-old Guevara, son of ’90s heartthrob Marisol Torres, infused Nick with brooding intensity. Their kiss in the rain? A global sensation, racking up 100 million views on social media. Critics praised the adaptation’s fidelity to the books, but it was the leads’ palpable spark that turned casual viewers into obsessives.

Off-screen, the pair were inseparable during the My Fault press tour. Instagram stories showed them laughing at after-parties, sharing inside jokes in interviews, and even vacationing together in Marbella. Fans dubbed them “GabiCole,” and shipping exploded. “They look at each other like they’re already in love,” one Reddit user gushed in a 2023 thread that garnered 5,000 upvotes. By October 2023, speculation peaked: Were they dating? Guevara liked flirty comments on fan edits, and Wallace posted cryptic stories with heart emojis over their joint photos. But then, the unfollow heard ’round the world—on November 1, 2023, Wallace quietly removed Guevara from her Instagram follows, sparking a frenzy. Theories swirled: a lovers’ quarrel? Professional jealousy? Enter the girlfriend factor.

Gabriel Guevara’s relationship with María de Nati, a 27-year-old rising star known for roles in La Mesías and Intimidad, went public in early 2024, mere months after the unfollow drama. Paparazzi snaps of the couple kissing at Madrid events went viral, with De Nati’s poised elegance contrasting Guevara’s bad-boy vibe. Fans were gutted; X timelines filled with broken-heart emojis under headlines like “GabiCole Shattered: Gabriel’s New Flame Steals the Spotlight.” De Nati, no stranger to the spotlight, has been vocal about her career but tight-lipped on the rumors. Insiders whisper she was “uncomfortable” with the intense GabiCole shipping, especially as Your Fault promotions ramped up. “Fans were editing her out of his life like she didn’t exist,” a source told BollywoodShaadis in October 2025. Guevara, for his part, doubled down on the romance, posting loving tributes to De Nati while maintaining a frosty distance from Wallace at events. Yet, their on-screen intimacy in Your Fault—a sequel amping up the stakes with college drama and a love triangle—only fueled the fire. How could they fake that heat if things were truly icy?

Cue the leaked fan theory, which dropped like a bombshell in November 2025, just weeks after Our Fault‘s release. Penned by an anonymous “set insider” on a gossip page called SpillTheCulpa (now defunct amid DMCA takedowns), the 2,000-word breakdown claims to catalog six specific “accidental touches” from across the trilogy’s shoots. These aren’t your run-of-the-mill bloopers; they’re moments where, the theory argues, professionalism cracked under unspoken desire. With Guevara’s girlfriend in the mix, each one reads like a betrayal, turning innocent mishaps into tabloid gold.

The first “touch” hails from My Fault‘s iconic pool scene. In the final cut, Nick pulls Noah close during a tense confrontation, their hands brushing underwater in a scripted move. But a leaked blooper reel, circulating on X since 2024, shows an extra beat: Guevara’s hand lingers on Wallace’s waist post-take, his thumb tracing a slow circle as she giggles and swats him away. “It wasn’t in the script—that was pure instinct,” the theory claims, citing a crew member’s alleged testimony. Fans pored over the clip, pausing at 0:47 to spot the “accidental” graze. “He’s touching her like he owns her,” one X user commented, racking up 10,000 likes. Scandalous? Absolutely, especially knowing De Nati was waiting in Guevara’s trailer, scrolling through fan theories that painted her as the villain.

Touch number two unfolds during Your Fault‘s motorcycle chase—a high-adrenaline sequence where Nick teaches Noah to ride. Script calls for a quick hand-over-hand adjustment on the handlebars. Leaked set footage from a 2024 wrap party screening reveals more: As the director yells “cut,” Guevara doesn’t let go. Instead, he slides his fingers along Wallace’s knuckles, intertwining them briefly before pulling away with a sheepish grin. The theory labels it “The Hold That Lingered,” arguing it betrayed months of pent-up tension post-unfollow. “Gabriel’s eyes say it all—he’s fighting himself,” the analysis notes, zooming in on his conflicted expression. X erupted, with #AccidentalTouch trending briefly in Spain, as shippers clashed with De Nati defenders. “Disrespectful to María. Grow up,” one reply read, while another quipped, “If that’s accidental, my coffee spills on purpose every morning.”

By the third installment, Our Fault, the trilogy’s emotional climax involving family secrets and a potential breakup, the “touches” allegedly escalated. The third incident: a quiet rehearsal for the film’s tender bedroom reconciliation. B-Roll shared by director Marta Buchaca in a 2025 making-of featurette shows Wallace and Guevara running lines alone in a dimly lit hotel room set. As Noah delivers a monologue, Nick’s hand “accidentally” brushes her thigh while shifting on the bed—far from the scripted arm drape. The clip cuts abruptly, but eagle-eyed fans slowed it to 0.5x speed, spotting Wallace’s flush and Guevara’s quick apology. “That’s not acting; that’s chemistry leaking off the page,” the theory asserts, linking it to reports of on-set arguments where Guevara allegedly stormed off, frustrated by their “always the same” dynamic. With De Nati promoting her own project Echoes of Silence concurrently, tabloids speculated jealousy boiled over: Did she demand distance, only for the pair’s gravitational pull to defy orders?

The fourth touch, dubbed “The Elevator Escape,” comes from Your Fault‘s claustrophobic lift scene, where Noah and Nick share a charged silence amid a building fire. Post-take, as elevators ding open, Guevara’s arm snakes around Wallace’s lower back to guide her out—a knightly gesture, sure, but the theory highlights how his fingers splay possessively, dipping just below her shirt hem. Leaked by a disgruntled PA on Reddit in July 2025, the photo went viral, amassing 200,000 views. “Accidental my foot. That’s boyfriend behavior,” fans chorused. Yet, context matters: This was mere weeks after Guevara’s Venice Film Festival arrest scandal (he was later cleared of sexual assault charges from his minor years), a low point that saw Wallace post supportive (if vague) feminist messages. Was the touch reassurance? Or something steamier?

Numbers five and six ramp up the intimacy. The fifth, from Our Fault‘s beach bonfire, involves an unscripted wave crash that soaks them both. Laughing, Guevara helps Wallace up, his hands cupping her elbows—then sliding to her hips in a steadying grip that lasts 12 seconds too long, per the theory’s timestamped breakdown. X semantic searches reveal dozens of fan recreations, with one post from @yanauzunova1 capturing the moment: “The way Gabriel can’t stay without touching her even for a sec.” The sixth and most incendiary? A late-night My Fault reshoot in 2023, where, during a rain-soaked kiss retake, Guevara’s “accidental” forehead press against Wallace’s lingers into a nuzzle, their breaths syncing audibly. Audio from the leak picks up Wallace whispering, “Gabe, we’re good,” before they break apart, flushed. Posted on a gossip page in November 2025, it shattered X records for #GabiCole mentions, peaking at 1.2 million.

So, why does this matter now, with the trilogy wrapped and stars moving on? Because it underscores Hollywood’s timeless trope: the lovers who love too much. Wallace, 23, has since starred in Raising Voices (2024), earning acclaim for her advocacy against director Eduard Cortés’ abuse allegations—a stance Guevara notably sidestepped, adding feud fuel. She’s been spotted with a mystery “novio” at Madrid clubs, fueling rebound rumors, while Guevara, 24, and De Nati attended the Our Fault premiere arm-in-arm, all smiles for the cameras. Yet, in a recent promo video, their separate-sofa interview—Wallace on one end, Guevara on the other—screamed awkward. “They could’ve sat closer, but nah,” an X user lamented.

The theory isn’t without critics. Skeptics call it cherry-picked obsession, pointing to body-shaming rumors (Guevara allegedly mocked Wallace’s figure for intimate scenes) and professional rifts as the real culprits. “Shipping is fun until it invades privacy,” De Nati subtly shaded in a 2025 Elle interview. Mercedes Ron, the author, has stayed neutral, tweeting, “Nick and Noah’s story is fiction—let the actors live theirs.” But for fans, the touches symbolize what could have been: a romance as epic as their characters’.

In the end, these “accidents” remind us why we watch. In a industry rife with scripted perfection, the unpolished moments—the unintended brushes, the stolen glances—feel achingly real. Whether GabiCole was ever more than a fever dream, one thing’s clear: Wallace and Guevara’s spark lit up screens worldwide, leaving us all a little heartbroken. As Our Fault fades to black, perhaps that’s the trilogy’s true fault: making us believe in love that’s just out of reach. 💔